Bernard Herrmann: The Sound of Suspense

“I always think that film music expresses what the actor can’t show or tell.”
—Bernard Herrmann, interviewed by Ted Gilling, Sight and Sound, 1971–72

“I feel that music on the screen can seek out and intensify the inner thoughts of the characters… It can propel narrative forward or slow it down. It often lifts mere dialogue into the realm of poetry,”So wrote Bernard Herrmann for a 1972 London recording

“My feelings and yearnings are those of a composer of the 19th century. I am completely out of step with the present.”
-Bernard Herrmann in a letter to his wife

“He depends on music and often photographs a scene knowing that music will complete it.”—Bernard Herrmann, interviewed by Ted Gilling, Sight and Sound, vol. 41, no. 1 (1971/72), pp. 36–39; by Cinescores. “He” refers explicitly to Hitchcock in the preceding sentence.

On music as Hitchcock’s weapon of suspense:
“I think that Hitchcock’s films depend enormously on music to build his nutcracker of suspense, and to impose on him a kind of pop culture is to deprive him of one of the greatest weapons in his arsenal.”

—From the same Ted Gilling interview. This is the full sentence as reproduced in the transcript. Herrmann was discussing the end of their collaboration and his objection to the pressure for pop-oriented music.

On Hitchcock adapting his editing to the score:
“Hitchcock, for example, is very anxious for you to tell him when you see a rough cut where you plan to use music, because if you’re using music, he’ll cut it differently.”

—From the same interview. This gives you a specific account of how the collaboration worked: the planned music could affect Hitchcock’s editing, rather than simply being added to a finished sequence.

On their break—sharper and more confrontational:
“Because … he only finishes a picture 60 percent. I have to finish it for him.”

—Bernard Herrmann, interviewed by Royal S. Brown in August 1975. The ellipsis appears in the published transcript; The interview first appeared in High Fidelity in September 1976 and was revised for Brown’s Overtones and Undertones (1994). The Bernard Herrmann Society reproduces it with a note explaining that the original recording was consulted to restore deletions and some of Herrmann’s original wording.

In the Gilling interview, Herrmann also recalls Hitchcock saying, about Vertigo: Alfred Hitchcock, as recalled by Bernard Herrmann.
“If we’re going to have music, we won’t have one word of dialogue; we’ll just have the camera and you.”

Composer Miklos Rozsa reportedly said:
“Herrmann was a Gulliver among the film music Lilliputians.”

“The thing about Herrmann was that he was a forceful personality and that force in his personality found its voice in those hammering, repetitive themes of his, which you can’t get out of your ear. – Composer John Williams

Before the Image, a Voice- Bernard Herrmann and the music beneath the surface

I often feel that Bernard Herrmann’s music reaches a character’s inner life before the film has found the words for it. It doesn’t merely accompany danger or alert us to the fact that danger is near; it draws us into and lets us also feel their dread, longing, obsession, or loneliness. Before we know its name, we know the sound.

A shower curtain opens, and violins turn into an assault. A woman emerges through a ghostly green light, and the orchestra swells with an obsessive love so desperate that it can no longer distinguish a person from a beautiful phantasm. A taxi moves through Manhattan steam, and the music offers two versions of the city: one is seductive, the other already burning.

These are not merely memorable musical textures or the voices of films like Psycho, Vertigo, and Taxi Driver. They are part of what those films mean. Bernard Herrmann could make an orchestra reveal something that a character would never admit, or that a director preferred to leave unresolved. His music did not always tell us what was happening, but it did tell us what happening felt like, from somewhere dangerously far inside.

Bernard Herrmann’s biographer Steven C. Smith, the author of A Heart at Fire’s Center: The Life and Music of Bernard Herrmann, finds much of Herrmann’s genius in his ability to evoke psychological nuance, and in the way he brought together just the right instruments to give each film its own emotional undercurrents and draw us closer to the characters’ fear and desires.

You may know Bernard Herrmann’s music whether you realize it or not. Think of the dark snarling brass that opens Citizen Kane, the spiraling arpeggiated phrases of Vertigo, or the headlong rush of North by Northwest. Those strings that slash the air in Psycho, the saxophone drifting through Taxi Driver, and, of course, each belongs so completely to its film that it is hard to imagine the images without it in the realm of modern cinema.

Yet there is much more to Herrmann than menace. He could give The Magnificent Ambersons a tenuous elegance, then summon the enormous forces that seem to shake the ground beneath Mysterious Island. Across that range, you can still hear his signature: short phrases that won’t let go, chords that seem suspended in midair, and moments when the music opens unexpectedly into longing. Listen to brass voices plunging in Cape Fear or the sinister whistling theme from Twisted Nerve. The music leaves us unsettled, waiting for a resolution that never quite arrives.

The title The Sound of Suspense fits him, but suspense is only the beginning. Herrmann also understood solitude, tenderness, grief, and the peculiar terror of wanting something that could save you in the end or finally bring you relief, while the threat that you might never attain it feels all too real.

But his music could just as readily open its arms to romance, catch the exhilaration of an adventure, or give us the wonder of stepping into a world we had never imagined. He had room for the whole sweep of feelings, from the smallest private hope to the grandest leap into the unknown. Maybe beneath the famous shocks lies a composer of longing: for lost childhoods (Citizen Kane), unreachable lovers (the heartbreaking separation between Lucy Muir and the ghostly sea captain in The Ghost and Mrs. Muir), vanished worlds (The Magnificent Ambersons – the family’s privileged world gives way to industrial change. His soundtrack captures the loss of an entire social order, not simply one person’s happiness) Herrmann’s score belongs to that story of decline and displacement, and human contact that arrives too late (Taxi Driver, On Dangerous Ground) or at a price. His reputation for terror can overshadow the yearningly romantic side of his music, particularly in North by Northwest and The Ghost and Mrs. Muir. All of it belongs to the emotional territory of his work. He could also make room for love fulfilled, horizons opening, and the sheer joy of being swept into something larger than ourselves.

Bernard Herrmann might have preferred to be celebrated for his opera Wuthering Heights, his symphonies, his cantata Moby Dick, and his other concert works. Yet, according to fellow film composer John Williams, Herrmann’s greatest ambition was to earn recognition as a conductor. Whatever recognition he hoped for, the movies became the place where his imagination left its deepest mark. He helped change not just how films sounded, but what they could say through music, and generations of composers have been listening ever since. That was “his great skill—his understanding of the psychology of the character,” fellow film composer Howard Shore said. Herrmann could hear what was happening beneath a character’s words and actions, then give it musical expression. His scores brought us closer to the fears, desires, and contradictions driving the people on screen.

Herrmann’s music could stir a feeling, resist it, or give it an unexpected gravity. The psychology was in the encounter—not only in the person, but in what happened when that person met the world.

Continue reading “Bernard Herrmann: The Sound of Suspense” →

Noirvember! Where the Sidewalk Ends 1950: A Badge Is No Alibi

Where the Sidewalk Ends 1950

It’s Noirvember, a time to celebrate the shadowy riches of film noir, and in Where the Sidewalk Ends, the badge is no guarantee you’re on the right side of trouble.

In Otto Preminger’s Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950), Gene Tierney reunites with her Laura director and co-star Dana Andrews, this time in a supporting role.

Andrews takes center stage as Detective Mark Dixon, a cop with old ghosts knocking around in his head. Unfortunately, he has brought his fists along. He despises criminals, a hatred rooted in his father’s life on the wrong side of the law. Brutal and heavy-handed, his contempt for the criminal element is tangled up with his own family shame and repressed guilt that spills into his work, and without a whisper of conscience, he doesn’t think twice about roughing up a suspect to get him to talk. Dixon wears his badge as though it might finally put some distance between himself and his father’s crooked, shady past. But the disgrace brands him like a second badge, and he takes it out on the men he pursues. Bitter and quick with his fists, he would rather knock an answer out of a suspect than wait for one. Dixon’s brand of justice casts a shadow that stretches all the way to Dirty Harry. Rules do little to hold back a cop who thinks the law gives criminals too much room to breathe. Set in a New York crawling with underworld lowlifes, the film follows Dixon’s relentless pursuit of gangster Tommy Scalise (Gary Merrill), who once ran with his father. Preminger portrays Dixon as a solitary figure, haunted by his past and increasingly unable to separate his inner demons, pulling him from the moral line he’s supposed to walk. He’s made a name for himself down at the 16th Precinct, though the complaints piling up against him have given that name a black eye. Because he’s obsessed with the painful knowledge of being a thief’s son, Dixon spends his life trying to put distance between himself and his father, a shadow he can’t shake. His hatred of criminals, especially Scalise, runs so deep that he starts borrowing their methods to bring them down, until justice becomes a grudge that has turned to poison and a private vendetta.

This is the last in a series of films that Otto Preminger made as a director-for-hire for Twentieth Century Fox in the 1940s. The series includes Laura (1944), which also stars Gene Tierney and Dana Andrews, Fallen Angel (1945), and, once again, Tierney as a troubled society wife whose secret kleptomania leaves her at the mercy of a scheming hypnotist in Whirlpool (1950).

Dana Andrews and Gene Tierney in Laura, where a detective falls under the spell of a beautiful woman’s portrait and the ghost steps out of the frame.

Joseph LaShelle, who won an Oscar for the polished black-and-white world of Laura, gives Where the Sidewalk Ends a burnished edge with considerably less room to breathe. Tightly paced and beautifully shot, the film brings out the bite in Hecht’s writing and feels tailor-made for Preminger. The photography draws on a smoky greyscale, letting soft silvers deepen into bruised blacks and giving the shadows both richness and grit. His other work from Fallen Angel and Road House to Billy Wilder’s The Apartment suggests a cinematographer equally at home with noir’s unease and the loneliness of an ordinary room. Here, working with Preminger’s fluid camera movements and sustained takes, he makes cramped apartments, nighttime streets, and shadowed interiors feel like extensions of Dixon’s predicament: there is space to move, but nowhere to feel entirely safe. The camera does not keep announcing his guilt with a dramatic flourish; it follows him with a patient attention that becomes its own kind of pressure. Even an apparently straightforward passage involving a car elevator gains its suspense through the positioning of the men inside it. The shadows supply the atmosphere, but the careful arrangement of bodies and spaces makes the danger feel close enough to touch.

Preminger and LaShelle give that anxiety room to develop. The direction favors fluid movement and sustained takes over a barrage of emphatic close-ups; the camera follows people through rooms with an ease their lives conspicuously lack. LaShelle’s black-and-white photography makes the city feel both inhabited and inhospitable, a place of temporary shelter rather than safety. One particularly effective shot is that extended, fixed, no-cut take of the car carrying Dixon, Scalise, and his men approaching and entering the car elevator, then rising off-screen as they watch each other suspiciously.

The movement is simple, but the arrangement leaves us studying the men inside, waiting for suspicion to become action. Nothing needs to leap out of the shadows when the company is already this bad. Preminger and LaShelle’s off-kilter camera angles and touches of the outlandish, skewed environment give ordinary places an uneasy edge, keeping the suspense grounded in a world we recognize.

Where the Sidewalk Ends film takes its title literally: before we meet Dixon, we’re already looking at the pavement. The film brings us down to street level before the story even begins. There’s no familiar Twentieth Century-Fox fanfare; instead, with an everyday, almost offhand quality, someone whistles Alfred Newman’s ubiquitous “Street Scene” theme as the opening credits appear in chalk on the sidewalk. A pedestrian walks right over the lettering, as though the movie’s introduction were just another part of the pavement. It’s an unassuming entrance, but it sets the right tone for a film about the uneasy distance between a policeman’s authority and the street he patrols. Newman wrote the “Street Scene” theme, but Cyril J. Mockridge composed the film’s score, incorporating Newman’s music.

In Laura, polished manners and expensive taste give murderous possessiveness a respectable place at high society’s table.
In Where the Sidewalk Ends, it doesn’t need any introduction. Preminger takes us downstairs and out into a city where money runs short, tempers run hot, and a badge does not necessarily mean the man wearing it will keep his hands to himself. Violence is no scandalous intrusion here; it is part of the neighborhood’s vocabulary, spoken by crooks and policemen who seem to share the same fluency.

Laura and Where the Sidewalk Ends might take place in the same city, but they tell their stories in very different neighborhoods. Preminger brings Andrews and Tierney back together again, in cramped rooms, modest restaurants, and streets where nobody has much left to lose. Where the earlier film’s characters trade sharp remarks, people here are quicker to throw a punch.

Six years after Laura, Preminger reunites the two stars, and cinematographer Joseph LaShelle, but the elegant rooms and cultivated malice have given way to cheap apartments, gambling joints, and police offices where nobody looks particularly well rested. Film-noir historian Eddie Muller neatly described the change of address as going “from the penthouse to the outhouse.”

Andrews plays the volatile New York Detective Mark Dixon as a man whose anger has become second nature, leaving everyone around him to deal with its consequences. He’s already been warned by his superiors that his fists are doing too much of the questioning, especially when he visits a suspect’s apartment and turns an interrogation into a fight that leaves the man dead and the cop with something of his own to hide.

Dixon’s anger and violence make him a rougher figure than Andrews’s earlier detective. Tierney’s beauty remains, but here it belongs to a working woman modeling clothes for a department store, not a portrait holding a room in its spell. And Andrews seems to have carried his detective’s composure into the next guy’s harsher life: Mark Dixon wears the familiar trench coat, a visual callback to Laura’s Mark McPherson, but beneath it is a man whose weariness has hardened into anger. Bright Lights Film Journal makes a similar comparison, describing Dixon as “an older, sadder, more disturbing version of the cool cop in a trench coat.”

The screenplay is by Ben Hecht, adapted from William L. Stuart’s novel Night Cry, with adaptation credits for Victor Trivas, Frank P. Rosenberg, and Robert E. Kent. Its setup is beautifully unpleasant: what happens when a detective investigating one killing commits another, then uses his professional knowledge to keep himself out of the investigation? Hecht gives the machinery a sharp conversational edge. Everyone in this film rarely wastes a sentence when a verbal jab will do the trick.

Preminger and screenwriter Ben Hecht follow Dixon into an inferno of guilt and the cruel chance of fate, where one unintended death exposes the damage done long before he threw that fatal punch. His deepest reckoning is the recognition that he did not stumble into this nightmare unprepared: every suspect he brutalized, every act of cruelty he mistook for toughness, helped fashion the trap that finally closed around him.

Dana Andrews hardly looks like a man forever one insult away from throwing a punch, but that controlled exterior makes the anger beneath it even more unsettling. His detective sets out to conceal his own guilt with grim efficiency, only to steer the investigation toward an innocent cab driver.

By the early fifties, noir was finding plenty to fear on the supposedly reassuring side of the law. Where the Sidewalk Ends belongs to that uneasy company of films in which a detective’s anger becomes a danger in its own right. Think of Robert Ryan’s Jim Wilson in Nicholas Ray’s On Dangerous Ground (1951), a lonely, embittered cop whose disgust with the people he arrests has turned into a habit of brutality. Then there’s Van Heflin’s chilling portrayal of sociopathic cop Webb Garwood in Joseph Losey’s The Prowler (1951), who belongs in this company too, though his weakness is less a quick temper than a hunger for someone else’s comfortable life. When he’s called to investigate a prowler, he finds Evelyn Keyes, who plays Susan Gilvray, and he decides that he wants her and her home for himself. His badge gets him through the door, but it winds up being no protection for the people who let him in.

The badge may give Dixon authority, but it does not give him mastery over himself. Like Kirk Douglas’s detective in Detective Story, Jim McLeod’s father was a violent man who drove his mother into a mental institution. Dixon carries his father’s criminal past into every confrontation, treating each crook as another opportunity to settle a family grievance. But where Douglas burns with the conviction that he is right, Andrews seems worn down by the suspicion that something is wrong with him. One turns self-righteousness into a weapon; the other keeps finding his own reflection in the people he wants to punish.

These are the troubled precincts of noir, the territory where Where the Sidewalk Ends shares a neighborhood with Detective Story and The Prowler. Here, the question is not merely whether the police can catch a dangerous man, but whether they can recognize one behind a badge.

Mark Dixon is already in trouble when we meet him. His superiors have had enough of his treatment of suspects, and a demotion puts him under Lieutenant Thomas, played by Karl Malden.

“You don’t hate hoodlums; you like to beat them up. You get fun out of it.” Inspector Nicholas Foley, played by Robert Simon

Dixon and his partner Paul (Bert Freed) return to the precinct to find a new authority in place: Lieutenant Thomas, a man with little patience for departures from the rulebook.

Thomas has advanced without Dixon’s habit of leaving bruises behind him; Malden gives his authority an earnest firmness that makes him more troublesome than a conveniently foolish superior would have been. Dixon cannot simply dismiss the man investigating his conduct as incompetent. The department’s warning is clear: another incident could finish him. Naturally, another incident is waiting just around the corner.

Inspector Foley (Robert F. Simon) makes the introductions, then pulls Dixon aside for a less cordial exchange and to lay down the law. “Your job is to detect criminals, not to punish them.” — Inspector Nicholas Foley.

Twelve brutality complaints have caught up with him, costing him his rank and earning him a demotion to second detective. Foley leaves no room for misunderstanding: unless Dixon reins himself in, his next assignment will be pounding a beat.

The trouble begins at a floating craps game at a hotel run by gangster Tommy Scalise, played by Gary Merrill, with a smug composure that practically invites someone to lose his temper.

The high-stakes dice game turns tense when wealthy Texan Morrison (Harry von Zell), flush with $19,000 in winnings, is ready to walk away and call it a night. Having brought him to the game, Ken Paine (Craig Stevens) is expected to keep him there long enough for Scalise to win back his money. Under pressure, Paine starts to get abusive with his estranged wife, Morgan Taylor (Gene Tierney), who is disgusted by the whole deal and is now refusing to keep playing her part in the setup. When she insists on leaving, their quarrel takes on an ugly edge. Paine strikes her, and Morrison, seeing it, steps in to defend her, and the two come to blows, where the Texan takes a knockout punch for his trouble. After that, Paine and Morgan leave.

Dixon and Paul catch a murder call at Scalise’s hotel. Morrison’s luck has run out: the big winner at the dice table is now a corpse, with a knife in the heart.

“Why are you always trying to push me in the gutter?” Scalise asks Andrews. “I have as much right on the sidewalk as you.”

Lieutenant Thomas arrives, and Scalise wastes no time pointing the finger at Paine, though he claims he never saw a knife. Dixon grabs Scalise’s address book and turns up Paine’s address. Thomas sends him to check it out, but Dixon has his own agenda: he wants Scalise, and Paine may be the lever he needs to bring him down.

Scalise keeps returning to his nasal inhaler, a little habit that suggests more than a stubborn cold. Lee Marvin’s Dill would nurse a similar attachment, fixated on his spray bottle in the superb color noir Violent Saturday (1955).

Craig Stevens as Paine in the seedy confines of his room in Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950).

Dixon sees this as an opportunity to get his old enemy, but what ought to be a routine questioning becomes the hinge on which the whole picture swings.

He walks into Paine’s fleabag room without bothering to knock. Paine is on the phone, deeper in the bottle than before, leaving a message for Morrison. Dixon cuts through the drunken haze and tells him Morrison is dead, Scalise has pointed the finger at him, and now he’s coming down to the station.

Paine doesn’t buy it and takes a swing. Dixon answers with a punch that drops him for good. All he did was deck him, but Dixon realizes he’s dead. Stevens gives Paine enough drunken hostility to make the confrontation ugly without making his death seem deserved.

The phone rings. His partner, Paul, calls with a warning that comes one blow too late. Go easy on Paine; he’s a war hero who’s fallen on hard times.

For Dixon, there is still a choice. He could report what happened. Instead, convinced that his reputation will make an accidental killing impossible to explain, he begins arranging the evidence into a more convenient story and planting false clues. He conceals the body, creates a false trail suggesting Paine has left town, and eventually disposes of the corpse in the river. The detective has become his own most resourceful accomplice.

With a dead man at his feet, Dixon trades police work for a cover-up. Now he’s got to get rid of the body. He packs Paine’s suitcase, calls a cab, and passes himself off as Paine on a trip to the train station, where he checks the luggage under the dead man’s name. The idea is to make it look as though Paine left town alive. But when Dixon returns to the room, Paul is already there, close to the secret, though he hasn’t figured it out yet. Bert Freed, as Dixon’s partner Paul Klein, supplies another kind of grounding presence: the everyday proximity of a colleague becomes distinctly uncomfortable when you are depending on everyone overlooking what is right in front of them.

Mark Dixon (Dana Andrews) stays hidden in the hallway as Jiggs Taylor (Tom Tully) arrives at Ken Paine’s apartment in Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950).

They question the landlady, who tells them she saw Paine leave, giving Dixon’s deception a witness. He drops Paul at headquarters, then doubles back to finish the job. But as he hauls the dead guy into the hall, someone arrives. Dixon ducks beneath the stairs with his dead weight and waits in the shadows. The guy at Paine’s door is Morgan’s father, Jiggs, whose temper is fueled by Paine’s mistreatment of his daughter, and he’s come to settle things. He gets no answer and stalks off with his anger still, looking for a target, never knowing how close he’s come.

Dixon dumps the body in the river and heads back to the precinct, where he and Paul are told to get some rest.

Dixon hopes to pin Paine’s death on Scalise. Instead, the investigation turns toward Morgan’s father, cab driver Jiggs Taylor, played by Tom Tully. Jiggs has threatened Paine over how he treated Morgan and has been seen at his apartment. Dixon’s carefully improvised escape route now leads straight to an innocent man. Tully’s good nature works enormously well to gain our sympathy: Jiggs is not merely a complication in Dixon’s cover-up but a father whose protective anger has made him vulnerable to his horrible mistake. The cruel extra detail: a war wound had left Paine with a metal plate in his skull, turning a single punch into a death sentence. Dixon’s violence has killed one man, and his silence is now threatening another.

Dana Andrews as Mark Dixon and Bert Freed as Paul Klein, his fellow detective and partner in Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950).

As Dixon, he’s always on guard, and that watchfulness becomes a kind of confinement: his anger has nowhere to go except outward toward others while he keeps his shame to himself. His face doesn’t give much away, but the effort of keeping it that way tells us plenty. What makes the performance so affecting, though, is the warmth that occasionally escapes his guard. When Dixon takes Morgan to his usual restaurant, his teasing exchanges with Martha briefly reveal a man who knows how to enjoy someone’s company.

Ruth Donnelly’s sharp-tongued Martha gives him a hard time, but there’s warmth in their back-and-forth and an affection that neither of them feels obliged to announce. For a few minutes, he’s not a detective trying to hide what he’s done, just a regular customer trading wisecracks. It’s a relief to see him relax, which makes it even sadder when he has to go back to covering his tracks.

Martha, Owner of Martha’s Cafe: You know, I like places like this that specialize in good food instead of headwaiters.
Det. Mark Dixon: It’s the worst food in town, but don’t worry. They usually serve a stomach pump with the dessert.
Martha: Who invited you to come to my restaurant, Mr. Detective? Not me!
Mark Dixon: Martha’s the head of a ring of burglars. My presence makes her nervous.
Martha: Yeah, last night we got a whole basketful of diamonds. You wanna see?
Mark Dixon: Bring us two of your dangerous dinners, Martha.
Martha: You know how much I’ve been offered to poison this man?
Mark Dixon: Ten dollars.
Martha: That’s right. I’m holding out for fifteen. Two dinners. Do you want wine?
Mark Dixon: Bring a small bottle.
Martha: Huh! Same old cheapskate!
Morgan: [after Martha leaves] She adores you, doesn’t she?
Martha: She ought to. I sent her husband up.
Morgan: Was he really a burglar?
Mark Dixon: Wife beater.

There is welcome oxygen in Ruth Donnelly’s Martha, the diner owner whose brisk manner suggests that a difficult customer is hardly a new species, and affection for Dixon takes the form of mocking threats like cheerfully advertising homicide herself with their quick banter, “You know how much I’ve been offered to poison this man?” she asks. Dixon supplies the figure: “Ten dollars.” Martha is not denying the offer: “That’s right. I’m holding out for fifteen.” For once, the threats come with a cafe dinner rather than a smoke-filled interrogation room. Donnelly steals all her scenes, and her presence is there to remind us that the city holds ordinary people getting on with their lives.

Ruth Donnelly (1896–1982) was a stage-trained character actress whose specialty was drollery: she had a way with brisk delivery, dry humor, and the unmistakable impression that she had heard every excuse in the book before. After establishing herself on Broadway, including in plays by George M. Cohan, she became a familiar Hollywood presence in the 1930s, playing sharp-tongued secretaries, practical-minded friends, and no-nonsense wives who were rarely inclined to suffer foolishness quietly.

Donnelly’s dry wit livened up Footlight Parade as the formidable Mrs. Gould, and she appeared in A Slight Case of Murder as a gangster’s sharp-tongued wife. She also brought a worldly kindness to Sister Michael in The Bells of St. Mary’s and played the warm-hearted Ruth, a fellow patient in Anatole Litvak’s The Snake Pit 1948 starring Olivia de Havilland. Here, she makes Martha the sort of woman who can offer you a meal and cut you down to size without interrupting bringing you the bottle of ketchup. Her briskness has warmth beneath it, and in a film crowded with suspicion, her teasing gives Dixon a rare moment for human ease and for him to catch his breath.

“Innocent people can get into terrible jams too,” Dixon tells Morgan, before adding, “One false move and you’re over your head.” He knows rather more about that predicament than he can afford to explain. His words are meant to reassure her, but he’s still keeping his own part in her father’s trouble to himself.

By now, Morgan is beginning to trust the very man who knows why her father shouldn’t be in custody. Tierney isn’t playing another elusive Laura. Morgan is more down-to-earth, a working woman with a bruising marriage behind her and an unlucky father to worry about. Her part isn’t as richly developed as Andrews’s, but she brings a quiet, subtle openness (something Tierney is masterful at) to their scenes that makes his guardedness even more obvious.

She does not seem to be auditioning to redeem a troubled detective; she believes she has met someone dependable. Her trust makes his deception worse. Dixon is falling for a woman whose life he has helped turn upside down.

Dixon watches as Jiggs and Morgan are hauled into the murder scene and grilled, put through the wringer, every question tightening the noose around the wrong man.

Tormented, sleep offers Dixon no refuge. By the next day, the river has surrendered Paine’s body, and his cover-up is falling on the wrong man. He tries to steer Lieutenant Thomas toward Scalise, but Thomas has fixed on Jiggs.

Lieutenant Thomas punctures the landlady’s story: the man she saw leaving wasn’t Paine but his killer, dressed to pass for him. He arrests Jiggs, and Dixon finds himself caught in a vise of his own making. His growing feelings for Morgan sharpen the torment because her innocent father is taking the fall for his crime.

Neville Brand as Steve, the muscle behind Gary Merrill’s gangster Tommy Scalise, in Otto Preminger’s Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950).

“I can’t figure you out. Your father liked me…” Dixon cuts him off: “Shut up!”

Desperate to break apart the case against Jiggs, Dixon corners Scalise at a steambath, hoping to squeeze out a confession to Morrison’s murder. Instead, Scalise’s muscle beats him unconscious. When he comes around, he stumbles through the haze to Morgan’s doorstep. She gives him a drink and insists he stay the night. She is actually offering shelter to the man whose secret has put her father behind bars.

Morgan: “I’ll fix your head. Come with me.” Dixon: “I suggest you use an axe.”

Andrews performance doesn’t ask us to mistake Dixon for an innocent man; he makes us watch a guilty one think his way out of a bad situation. The way he holds his jaw, the guarded pauses, the effort to keep his face professionally unreadable, all suggest someone discovering how much work it takes to appear ordinary.

In his TCM article “Otto Preminger’s Where the Sidewalk Ends on DVD, December 20, 2005, Jeremy Arnold writes: “His paranoia at being found out becomes our paranoia, too.” The film makes us anxious about Dixon being caught even though we know what he has done. It’s one of noir’s uncomfortable achievements: we know what he has done, yet every interruption threatens to catch us holding our breath for him.

Andrews could make an ordinary man look as though life has quietly worn him down. Whether he’s wearing a uniform or a rumpled suit, he seems unable to switch off, still turning things over in his mind, still working long after the rest of the man who badly needed to sleep.

As the evidence tightens around Jiggs, Dixon tries to help without admitting why he must. He borrows money from Paul to secure the best lawyer in New York for Jiggs, but the attorney turns Morgan away. With that hope gone, Dixon offers the woman he’s falling for the one assurance he has no right to give: her father will soon be cleared. Morgan tells him he can’t know what it means to have a father in jail. And those words strike open an old wound. Quietly, Dixon tells her about his own father, a thief, shot while trying to escape. For a moment, the cop with an answer for everything has nothing to hide behind but the truth about his past.

When Morgan drifts off to sleep, Dixon puts his guilt on paper: a confession addressed to Inspector Foley, to be opened if he doesn’t come back alive. Then he leans on a parolee in Scalise’s outfit, forcing the man to take him to the boss. This time, Dixon makes sure the truth has a way out, even if he doesn’t.

Dixon leans on Willie Bender (Don Appell), a parolee in Scalise’s outfit, forcing him to arrange a meeting with the boss.

Dixon grows more desperate to catch Scalise, but his attempt to confront him ends in a beating rather than the way out he was looking for. Back at headquarters, Inspector Foley tells him off for his clumsy attempt at questioning Scalise, and the confrontation puts him on leave. He arranges another meeting with Scalise. His plan is less an escape than a way to punish himself: let the gangster kill him, and at least Scalise can be held accountable for that death, while the letter clears Jiggs. It is a drastic way to avoid having to tell the truth while still alive.

Even Scalise recognizes the arrangement; he understands how far his hatred has taken him and refuses to cooperate. Scalise: “It’s always a pleasure to watch a cop’s foreplay.” “I didn’t know a guy could hate that much,” he tells Dixon. “Not even you.” Coming from the gangster, it is a particularly ugly reminder of how far Dixon has fallen.

The meeting takes place inside Scalise’s hideout, a cavernous parking garage. Scalise taunts Dixon about his father, who provokes a confrontation and is shot in the arm, but Scalise stops him from being killed when he recognizes what Dixon is trying to pull off.

News then arrives that the police have uncovered the truth about the original crap-game killing. Scalise is about to finish him off when the police arrive. Scalise and his men attempt to escape in the car elevator, but Dixon stops it, trapping them by cutting the power to the building, turning the garage into a cage with Scalise and his men caught inside.

Back at the precinct, Foley congratulates Dixon and returns his letter unopened. His confession still sealed. There it is: a clean exit, for one last moment, the film offers Dixon precisely what he has been trying to find the whole time: a way out. But with Morgan beside him, Dixon hands it back to Foley. This time, he wants it read.

Foley respects the honesty, but it cannot wipe away Paine’s death. Dixon is placed under arrest. His last escape is the one he finally refuses, choosing reckoning over another lie. Morgan promises to stand by him, leaving the film on a bruised but hopeful note: he has lost his freedom, but not his chance at a different life. For the noir antihero, redemption isn’t getting away clean; it’s finally refusing to let someone else pay for his sins.

Dana Andrews had a gift for making composure look like hard labor. Behind that ever-level voice of his and guarded expression, something was always pressing to get out: desire, humiliation, anger, fear, all those qualities rolled into one distinctive manner. In Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950), that tension becomes the engine of one of his most punishing performances. His Mark Dixon wears authority like armor, but it cannot protect him from the shame that lies beneath it. Andrews makes him both dangerous and painfully exposed, a man quick enough to throw a punch, yet helpless before the consequences that unfold. The restraint is never emptiness; it is containment. Andrews gives us a man who feels every bit of it but fights to keep it off his face. But Dixon is running out of room.

In Otto Preminger’s Laura (1944), Andrews’s Detective Mark McPherson has a dry wit and a slightly cocky confidence, until his professional detachment is compromised when his fascination with the woman whose apparent murder he’s investigating starts getting under his skin. He keeps playing it cool, but the case has become something much more – it becomes an increasingly private obsession, much more personal than he wants to admit. In Where the Sidewalk Ends, Dixon feels like that same controlled detective with his defenses worn down, stripped of his protective polished cool: desire still unsettles him, but this time anger and guilt are calling the shots.

Dana Andrews as drifter Eric Stanton and Linda Darnell as Stella, the waitress whose affections draw him into a scheme for money, in Otto Preminger’s Fallen Angel (1945).

In Preminger’s Fallen Angel (1945), Andrews plays Eric Stanton, a broke opportunist whose smooth talk barely disguises his hunger for money, sex, security, and status. He’s a closer cousin to Dixon: always sizing people up, looking for an advantage, and hoping he can talk his way past the consequences, until his conscience starts talking back. Both Stanton and Dixon think they can work the angles and come out clean, maneuvering their way out of any moral troubles. What neither counts on is how hard it becomes to keep lying when someone believes in him, and another person’s trust is harder to escape than suspicion. Caught between Alice Faye’s June Mills, the well-heeled good girl he marries for money, and Linda Darnell’s Stella, the sharp-edged femme fatale he wants but can’t afford, Stanton finds that June’s loyalty awakens a conscience and makes it harder to keep treating her love as just another angle.

William Wyler’s The Best Years of Our Lives (1946) turns that same reserve toward a more openly sympathetic figure. As returning bombardier Fred Derry, Andrews gives a quiet, battered dignity to a veteran whose wartime achievements don’t offer much help with the disappointments of civilian life. Beneath his good looks and easy charm is a man struggling to recover his confidence and find his place in the world. Here, the strain he’s suffering is less a threat than an emotional wound. It’s about pride fighting against humiliation, and survival alongside trauma. That vulnerability also helps explain why Dixon remains relatable even at his worst: Andrews lets us feel the hurt his characters cannot quite put into words; he can make a man’s inability to talk about his pain almost as eloquent as a confession.

As Morgan Taylor, Gene Tierney brings her unmistakable glamour down to street level, giving it the warmth and weariness of a woman who has had to live with other people’s damage. There is nothing remote about her here: she is a cabdriver’s daughter, fiercely devoted to her father, bruised by a marriage to a violent man, yet still willing to risk tenderness. Her beauty doesn’t place her above the film’s battered world; it makes the harshness around her feel all the more unforgiving.

Morgan is no femme fatale beckoning Dixon toward ruin. She is his reckoning, the woman whose trust makes his deception unbearable. Every kindness she offers him deepens the wound of what he knows: the man she turns to for help is the reason her father needs saving. Tierney gives that relationship its quiet emotional force, making Morgan not an escape from Dixon’s guilt but the person who gives him a reason to stop running from it.

Her character offers that redemptive faith and unconditional love to Dixon, who otherwise seems condemned to inhabit a bruised and sunless, unforgiving universe.

Joseph LaShelle’s cinematography gives Where the Sidewalk Ends much of its uneasy atmosphere. While he photographed Laura, here the elegance has a rougher edge. People are crowded into tight, claustrophobic spaces framed by doorways and windows, with LaShelle’s shadows adding to the sense of confinement. Dixon seems to have less room to move as his troubles mount. Yet the camerawork stays remarkably quiet.

Preminger keeps the camera moving with a fluid ease, cutting only when he needs to and saving the close-ups, a restraint that works perfectly with Andrews’s guarded performance. The camera gives us time to watch Dixon trying to keep himself together, without insisting on getting close enough to see every flicker of feeling.

As his career progressed, Preminger grew increasingly insistent on filming on location. Yet Where the Sidewalk Ends makes surprisingly discreet use of New York, favoring enclosed rooms and anonymous corners over streets that announce their address. An elevated train cuts through the night in the distance; Times Square flickers past a car window; the climactic parking garage opens into a cavern of concrete and machinery. These glimpses lend the picture texture.

Eddie Muller called Where the Sidewalk Ends“an unjustly overlooked gem,” and I would agree wholeheartedly; Muller always has his eye on rare noir gems like this one. What makes it work so well is how the cover-up winds up being more revealing than the crime. Dixon spends most of the picture mistaking punishment for justice and control for strength. His first real sign of hope comes when he stops trying to make the evidence go his way. For Noirvember, that is a satisfying variation on the familiar descent: the darkness does not disappear, but this guy finally quits asking it to hide him. His hardest arrest is his own.

Tidbits:

Gary Merrill’s Tom Scalisi was supposed to be a drug addict, but the Production Code prohibited any use or mention of narcotics. Gary Merrill’s character frequently uses a nasal inhaler, though showing no obvious signs of congestion. Developed in 1928, Benzedrine brand amphetamine was available without a prescription by 1934 as a nasal and bronchial decongestant, but it was also noted for its energizing side effects and stimulating, performance-enhancing qualities. It didn’t require a prescription until it was classified as a Schedule II controlled substance in 1959, which is how Scalise’s use of an amphetamine inhaler ducked the Production Code narcotics taboo of the day.

The only feature film appearance for fashion and costume designer Oleg Cassini, who was married to Gene Tierney at the time. They would divorce in 1952. Reportedly, Cassini talked director Otto Preminger into giving him the part.

This is your EverLovin’ Joey sayin’, watch your step, sweethearts; it’s Noirvember, and the sidewalk only goes so far!

MonsterGirl’s 150 Days of Classic Horror #107 NIGHT MUST FALL 1937 / SECRET BEYOND THE DOOR 1947 & NIGHT OF THE HUNTER 1955

SPOILER ALERT!

NIGHT MUST FALL 1937

You know, I still remember the first time I stumbled onto Night Must Fall—a vastly underrated British shocker, and honestly, it rattled me in a way few films from the 1930s ever have. Here I was, expecting a cozy little drawing-room mystery, maybe some clever repartee and a bit of melodrama, but what I got instead was this icy, slow-burn descent into the mind of a killer, years before “serial killer” was even a term in the public consciousness. There’s something deeply chilling about the idea that a film from 1937 could so nakedly explore the psychology of a psychopath, and not just as a shadowy figure lurking off-screen, but right there in the parlor, charming the socks off everyone—except, maybe, us.

And Robert Montgomery—my god, Montgomery! I’d always thought of him as the affable leading man from those fizzy 1930s comedies, but here, he’s a revelation. His Danny is all surface warmth and boyish charm, but you can feel the ice water running underneath. There’s this uncanny calm in the way he moves through the Bramson house, as if he’s rehearsed every gesture, every smile, every glint in his eye. It’s almost as if he’s studied people, learned how to mimic empathy, but never actually felt it. That “series of performances” quality—one minute he’s the devoted son figure, the next he’s whistling a tune with a cigarette dangling from his mouth, and then, with a flicker, you see the void behind his eyes.

What really got under my skin was how the film never lets you—or the characters—fully relax. The ticking clock, the way the camera lingers just a beat too long on a locked hatbox, the suffocating sense that something truly evil is at work, but it’s wearing a human face. Montgomery’s performance is so modern in its iciness, so heartless and yet so magnetic, that you can’t look away. There’s a moment where he’s alone, the mask slips, and you see that raw, festering wound of a person underneath—no glamour, just a kind of animal panic and emptiness. It’s a performance that anticipates everything from Psycho 1960 to In Cold Blood 1967, and it’s still as unnerving as anything you’ll find in later noir or horror.

Night Must Fall (1937) is one of those rare masterpieces of psychological suspense that leaves a mark. It’s about the terror of realizing that the real monster might be the person pouring your tea, the one everyone else finds so charming. The film’s darkness doesn’t just seep in from the edges—it’s right there, smiling at you, daring you to look away. Decades later, I still can’t shake the feeling it left me with. That’s the power of a film that truly understands how to get inside your head—and stay there.

Night Must Fall stands as a chilling landmark in psychological horror, translating Emlyn Williams’ stage success to the screen with unnerving precision under director Richard Thorpe. Adapted by John Van Druten, it moves with the slow, inexorable dread of a nightmare, its surface calm masking a psychological storm. The film plunges you into the claustrophobic world of Forest Corner, an isolated English estate where wealthy, cantankerous widow Mrs. Bramson (Dame May Whitty) feigns invalidism, reigning as a wheelchair-bound tyrant over her niece and companion. Her niece, Olivia Grayne (Rosalind Russell), is intelligent, repressed, and quietly resentful, trapped by financial dependence and emotional isolation. Mrs. Bramson also rules her household staff with manipulative cruelty. The household is completed by the tart-tongued cook Mrs. Terence, the anxious maid Dora (Merle Tottenham), and then there’s the unremarkable suitor Justin Laurie (Alan Marshal), whose proposals Olivia repeatedly rebuffs.

The film opens with the local police searching for Mrs. Shellbrook, dragging the river and scouring the countryside looking for a woman who has vanished from a nearby hotel. The mood at Forst Corner is already tense: Mrs. Bramson berates Dora for minor infractions, threatening her job until Dora, desperate, mentions her boyfriend Danny (Robert Montgomery), a page at the hotel. Danny arrives, bringing with him an air of breezy enchanment and a hint of something darker.

The arrival of Danny (Robert Montgomery), a disarmingly charming handyman engaged to the maid Dora, sets the plot in motion. Danny’s calculated charisma—a blend of Irish brogue and predatory charm—masks a sinister core, as evidenced by his unnerving habit of carrying a locked hatbox and his eerie fixation on decapitation. When a local woman is found murdered and headless near the estate, Olivia’s suspicions escalate into a visceral battle of wits and wills, torn between her dread of Danny and a dangerous, reluctant attraction.

He flatters Mrs. Bramson, quickly discerning her need for attention and motherly affection, and manipulates her into offering him a job as her personal attendant. Olivia is immediately suspicious, her intuition pricked by Danny’s effortlessly insincere charm and inconsistencies—she catches him lying about a shawl supposedly belonging to his mother, the price tag still attached.

As Danny insinuates himself into the household, the film’s tension ratchets up. Olivia’s suspicions are dismissed by Mrs. Bramson, who is increasingly besotted with Danny, calling him “my boy” and basking in his attentions.

Danny’s seduction of Mrs. Bramson’s affections in Night Must Fall is as cunning as it is seemingly innocent, and chocolates are one of his secret weapons. For Mrs. Bramson, chocolates aren’t just a treat—they’re a rare, almost forbidden luxury, a symbol of indulgence and comfort that she seldom allows herself. Living in her self-imposed isolation, surrounded by servants who resent her and a niece who barely tolerates her, Mrs. Bramson is starved for genuine attention and pleasure. Danny, with his instinctive knack for reading people’s desires, recognizes this immediately. He offers her chocolates with a flourish and a conspiratorial wink, transforming a simple sweet into a gesture of intimacy and delight. In Danny’s hands, chocolate becomes both a treat and a trap!

Danny, meanwhile, observes everything—Mrs. Bramson’s habit of locking cash in her safe, the routines of the staff, and Olivia’s wary intelligence. The outside world intrudes when Mrs. Bramson’s attorney, Justin, warns her about keeping so much cash at home, and the police visit to inquire about the missing Mrs. Shellbrook. The threat is close: a headless body is soon discovered in the woods near the house, and the entire village buzzes with morbid curiosity.

The discovery of the body brings a macabre celebrity to Mrs. Bramson’s house; she relishes the attention, even as Olivia’s anxiety grows. Danny’s duplicity becomes more apparent as he juggles his attentions between Dora (whom he has gotten pregnant and now avoids), Mrs. Bramson, and Olivia, whose mixture of suspicion and reluctant attraction to Danny gives their scenes a charged ambiguity. In a chilling sequence, the curious and suspicious household searches Danny’s belongings for evidence, their curiosity piqued by his heavy, locked hatbox—a possible hiding place for the missing head. Olivia, torn between fear and fascination, intervenes to protect him, claiming the hatbox as her own when the police arrive. This act, both reckless and intimate, binds her fate to Danny’s and deepens the film’s psychosexual undercurrents.

The film’s atmosphere, shaped by Ray June’s cinematography, is thick with shadow and silence: ticking clocks, creaking floorboards, and the omnipresent threat of violence. One of the most striking visual moments occurs after the body is found. This sequence isolates Danny in his dimly lit bedroom after the victim’s discovery:

Danny, alone in his room, is seen through his window, a box of light in the darkness, the camera tracking inward until ot hovers intimately, trapping us alongside his panic, his bravado stripped away. As night falls, the household fragments. Olivia, unable to bear the tension, leaves, urging Mrs. Bramson to do the same. The other servants depart, leaving Mrs. Bramson alone in the house with Danny. The old woman, now frightened by the noises and shadows she once dismissed, calls for Danny, who soothes her with gentle words and a drink—then, in a moment of cold calculation, suffocates her and empties her safe.

Danny’s murder of Mrs. Bramson unfolds with the chilling intimacy of a lullaby turned lethal. In the hush of the night, as shadows pool around the edges of her bed, he leans in with the gentleness of a dutiful son—his voice soft, his hands steady. The pillow, so often a symbol of comfort and rest, becomes in his grasp a velvet shroud. He lowers it, slow and deliberate, as if tucking her in against the world’s cruelties, but instead, he seals her away from breath and the morning that will never come for her again. The room fills with the silence of withheld air, the weight of unspoken terror pressing down until her struggles ebb, and the only sound left is the faint, final sigh of a life quietly extinguished beneath the guise of his affection and devoted care.

The film’s tension crescendos through the masterful cinematography by Ray June (he also directed two other psychological thrillers Barbary Coast (1935) – Nominated for an Academy Award for cinematography, which blends adventure with noirish visual style, and in 1950 Shadow on the Wall), who uses shadow and framing to mirror Danny’s fractured psyche.

Olivia returns, compelled by a need to confront the truth. She finds Danny preparing to burn the house and destroy the evidence. In a final confrontation, Danny confesses his resentment at being “looked down upon,” his sense of entitlement, and his belief that murder is his only way to assert himself. Danny tells her, “You’re afraid of yourself, aren’t you? You’re like me, really. Only you’re afraid to admit it.”

Olivia, her attraction now replaced by horror, tells him she sees him for what he is—a killer, as Danny moves to silence her. This visual claustrophobia amplifies the narrative’s dread, particularly as Danny’s facade crumbles—first suffocating Mrs. Bramson in her bed, then confessing to Olivia with manic glee, “Everything I love… dies.” The climax, where Danny prepares to burn the house with Olivia inside, is interrupted only by the timely arrival of Justin and the police, exposing his madness in a final, shattering confrontation.

The film’s power lies in its performances. Production anecdotes abound: Montgomery, captivated by the play, “badgered” MGM into casting him and funded part of the shoot, while Sherwood Forest, California, doubled for the English countryside. Robert Montgomery, cast against type, delivers a mesmerizing portrayal of Danny—a charming sociopath whose menace is all the more chilling for being cloaked in wit and vulnerability. Robert Montgomery’s performance as Danny remains the film’s spine, subverting his typical “matinee idol” persona to embody a narcissistic sociopath. Critics of the day were astonished; the National Board of Review named it the best film of 1937, and Montgomery received an Oscar nomination for Best Actor. His Oscar-nominated portrayal balances seductive wit with volcanic menace, particularly in scenes where he toys with Olivia’s fraying nerves.

Dame May Whitty, reprising her stage role, is equally compelling as Mrs. Bramson, her imperiousness giving way to terror in her final moments. It earned a Supporting Actress nomination for her turn as the manipulative matriarch, whose gullibility masks a latent terror. Rosalind Russell, in an early dramatic role, though initially overlooked, delivers a nuanced Olivia—icy yet vulnerable, hinting at the comedic prowess she’d later hone. She brings depth to Olivia’s conflicted intelligence and suppressed longing.

Let’s be honest: the true unsung heroines of Night Must Fall aren’t just the ones cowering in the shadow of Danny’s hatbox—they’re the two central staff women, each a comic archetype and a minor miracle of casting. First, we have Merle Tottenham’s Dora, the “pretty but naive and submissive” maid who spends the film in a state of perpetual fluster, as if she’s just remembered she left the kettle on and possibly also the back door open for a murderer.

Tottenham, who had a knack for playing the eternally put-upon servant (see her in This Happy Breed or Cavalcade), brings to Dora a kind of wide-eyed, breathless panic—she’s the sort of girl who’d apologize to a doorknob for bumping into it, and who, when confronted with a crisis, looks as if she’s about to faint into the nearest teacup. Then there’s Kathleen Harrison’s Mrs. Terence, the Cockney cook who is, frankly, the only person in the household with both feet on the ground and a tongue sharp enough to slice bread. Harrison’s style is pure British working-class comedy—she’s got a face like a weathered apple and the kind of voice that can cut through Mrs. Bramson’s self-pity like a hot knife through suet pudding. Mrs. Terence is the comic relief and the unofficial head of the Bramson household, forever muttering about her employer’s “malingering” and not above telling the old bat exactly what everyone else is too terrified to say. She’s the only one who isn’t remotely cowed by Mrs. Bramson’s theatrics, and she provides a much-needed dose of reality (and sarcasm) whenever the suspense threatens to get too thick.

Together, Dora and Mrs. Terence are like a mismatched vaudeville act: Dora, the human embodiment of a nervous squeak, and Mrs. Terence, the world-weary cynic with a rolling pin and a comeback for every occasion. They’re the glue that holds the Bramson house together, even as the whole place teeters on the edge of melodramatic disaster. If you ask me, they’re the only two who’d survive a sequel—Dora by accident, Mrs. Terence by sheer force of will and a well-timed eye-roll.

Contemporary critics were polarized. While some reviewers praised the film’s intelligence and restraint. “A marvelous, suspenseful, tension-filled, atmospheric thriller with absolutely NO ‘blood and guts’… the epitome of an intelligent horror film,” wrote one critic, noting that the film “really did give me the creeps and frightened me, especially in its closing scenes.” Others admired the adaptation’s ability to transcend its stage origins, crediting Thorpe’s direction and June’s cinematography for creating a sense of claustrophobic dread

While the New York Daily News hailed Montgomery’s “eminent position among top-notchers,” Graham Greene dismissed it as “a long, dim film… no more than a photographed stage play”

Audiences, warned by MGM’s unprecedented disclaimer trailer about the film’s “spurious content,” flocked regardless, drawn by its psychological audacity. Retrospectively, the film is celebrated for pioneering themes of repressed sexuality and class resentment—Danny’s rage at being “looked down upon” mirrors the era’s social anxieties—and its influence on later thrillers like Psycho is unmistakable.

Production anecdotes abound: Montgomery, captivated by the play, “badgered” MGM into casting him and funded part of the shoot, while Sherwood Forest, California, doubled for the English countryside.

Despite its tepid box office, Night Must Fall endures as a fine example of suspense, proving that true horror lies not in sensationalism or gore, but in the slow unraveling of a smile that hides a panicked scream.

Night Must Fall endures not just as a psycho-sexual horror film but as a proto-noir classic, remarkable for its psychological complexity, its subversion of genre expectations, and its exploration of the darkness lurking beneath ordinary lives. Its legacy is seen in later thrillers that probe the mind of the killer, and in its refusal to offer easy answers or catharsis. The film’s final image—Danny, exposed and defeated, but still defiant—lingers as a warning: evil is not always monstrous in appearance, but may arrive with a smile and a song at the door.

Dark Patroons & Hat Box Killers: 2015 The Great Villain Blogathon!

SECRET BEYOND THE DOOR 1947

There’s a singular, haunted beauty to Fritz Lang’s Secret Beyond the Door (1947), a film that feels like wandering through a dream where every corridor leads deeper into the labyrinth of the mind, like the myriad doors in Michael Redgrave’s murder tableaux in the film. It’s a work that wears its influences on its sleeve—Bluebeard 1944, Rebecca 1940, Gaslight 1944, and the Freudian fever of its era—but what Lang conjures is something uniquely his own: a psychological thriller that’s both lush and claustrophobic, as much a love letter to Gothic romance as it is a meditation on the architecture of fear.

The story begins with Celia Barrett, played by Joan Bennett with a mix of cool sophistication and vulnerable curiosity, an heiress whose life of privilege is upended by the sudden death of her brother. Celia’s older brother, Rick, dies early in the film, leaving her with a large trust fund and setting the story in motion. Adrift, she takes a holiday in Mexico, where she meets the enigmatic architect Mark Lamphere, portrayed by Michael Redgrave in his first Hollywood role. Their whirlwind romance is painted in sun-drenched colors, but even here, shadows flicker at the edges—a playful locking-out on their honeymoon turns into Mark’s abrupt withdrawal, and Celia is left alone, already sensing the chill that lies beneath his charm.

In Secret Beyond the Door, the moment when Mark Lamphere realizes his attraction to Celia is charged with a kind of electric, forbidden energy that lingers long after the scene fades. It happens in Mexico, in the thick of a sun-drenched plaza, where Celia and friend Edith (Natalie Schafer) stumble upon a knife fight erupting between two men over a woman. The violence is raw, almost ritualistic—a duel as old as myth, with the crowd pressing in, the air shimmering with heat and danger. Celia is transfixed, not recoiling but instead drawn in, her eyes wide with a secret thrill. She watches the woman at the center of the storm and, with a flicker of envy, wonders what it must feel like to inspire such passion—how proud that woman must be to cause death in the streets.

It’s here, in this fevered moment, that Mark notices Celia. He’s watching her as much as she’s watching the fight, his gaze like a hand tracing the outline of her excitement. There’s a current between them—Celia later describes it as “eyes touching me like fingers,” a tingling at the nape of her neck as if the air itself had turned cool and electric.

The violence in the street becomes a kind of mirror, reflecting the turbulence inside both of them. Mark is captivated by the hush before Celia’s smile, likening her to “wheat country before a cyclone—a flat, gold, shimmering stillness,” and when she smiles, it’s like the first gust of wind bending the fields, hinting at the storm beneath.

In that instant, the knife fight is more than a spectacle—it’s a catalyst, a spark that draws these two haunted souls together. Celia, intoxicated by the spectacle of danger and desire, finds herself seen in a way she never has before. Mark, in turn, is drawn not just to her beauty, but to the darkness he recognizes in her—a shared taste for the edge, for the thrill that comes just before chaos. The scene is a dance of glances and unsaid words, a duel played out not with knives but with longing, and it sets the tone for everything that follows: a love story built on the precipice of violence, where passion and peril are forever entwined.

The wedding in Secret Beyond the Door is a fevered vision—Lang’s camera lingers on the Mexican church, its arches and iconography forming a halo around Celia and Mark as they exchange vows. Circles and rings are everywhere: the semi-circular archway framing the church entrance, the ring of candles around the wishing well, the domed balcony railings, and the wedding ring itself—a motif that pulses with both promise and foreboding. The church is thick with religious imagery: saints gazing down in silent witness, the Virgin’s sorrowful eyes, and the flicker of votive candles casting halos of light and shadow. It’s a sacred space, but also a threshold—one that Celia, radiant and a little uncertain, steps across with a sense of both hope and gathering storm.

After the ceremony, the couple retires to their hacienda. There’s a lush, almost erotic haze to these honeymoon scenes: Celia, still in her bridal glow, is attended by a local woman who helps brush out her hair, the ritual both intimate and faintly ceremonial. The bedroom is airy, with white curtains billowing in the heat, and the world outside is all fountains and birdsong. But beneath the languor, tension coils. Mark, playful and teasing, is locked out of the bedroom by Celia—just a bit of newlywed mischief, she thinks, a way to prolong the anticipation. But when he finally returns, his mood has shifted. The playful spark in his eyes is replaced by a sudden chill; he’s distant, almost wounded, and soon after, he announces he must leave for urgent business in America, leaving Celia alone in the echoing villa.

That night—their wedding night—becomes the first fracture in Celia’s fairy tale. The lock on the bedroom door, meant as a flirtatious gesture, has instead triggered something dark and unresolved in Mark. She senses it at once: the way he withdraws, the way the room seems to grow colder, the sense that she’s suddenly on the wrong side of a threshold. The circular imagery that surrounded their union vanishes, replaced by the linear, shadowy corridors of the hacienda as Celia wanders, searching for her absent husband, her white nightgown ghostly in the moonlight.

It is only later that she understands the significance of that night—how her innocent prank awakened Mark’s childhood trauma, his terror of locked doors, and set in motion the chain of suspicion, secrecy, and psychological peril that will haunt their marriage. For all its beauty, the wedding is less a beginning than an initiation: a crossing into a world where love and danger are forever entwined, and every locked door is a question waiting to be answered.

When Celia arrives at Mark’s sprawling New England estate, Blade’s Creek, the film’s true atmosphere settles in: a house as much a character as any of its inhabitants, filled with locked doors, echoing hallways, and secrets that seem to seep from the walls. Here, Lang’s gift for visual storytelling is everywhere—Stanley Cortez’s chiaroscuro cinematography bathes the interiors in pools of light and shadow, every corner a potential hiding place for the past.

The supporting cast is a gallery of Gothic archetypes: Anne Revere as Caroline, Mark’s severe sister; Barbara O’Neil as Miss Robey, the veiled, enigmatic secretary whose scarred face and secretive manner recall Mrs. Danvers from Rebecca; and Mark’s estranged son David, who whispers to Celia that his father murdered his first wife.

The house itself is a museum of violence. Mark, whose fascination with murder borders on obsession, has built a wing of rooms that are meticulous recreations of infamous murder scenes—each one a shrine to a crime of passion, each one haunted by the memory of a woman’s death. At a party, Mark leads his guests through these rooms, narrating the grisly histories with a collector’s pride, but when they reach the seventh room, the door is locked and Mark refuses to open it. The tension is palpable, and Celia’s curiosity becomes a compulsion: what secret lies beyond that door?

As Celia settles into her new role as wife and detective, the film’s psychological machinery clicks into place. She is both observer and participant, her interior monologue (aided by Joan Bennett’s voiceover) guiding us through her mounting unease. Mark’s behavior grows more erratic—tender one moment, distant and cold the next, as if he’s at war with himself. Celia’s investigation brings her into uneasy alliance and rivalry with Miss Robey, who is revealed to be faking her disfigurement to keep her place in the household and whose loyalty to Mark is tinged with jealousy and resentment.

The pivotal moment comes when Celia, having stolen Mark’s key and made a copy, finally enters the forbidden seventh room. What she finds is a perfect replica of her own bedroom, a chilling confirmation of her worst fears: Mark has built a murder room for her, just as he did for his first wife. The revelation is underscored by Miklós Rózsa’s lush, anxiety-laced score, and for a moment, the film teeters on the edge of horror and a true merging of suspense and noir.

Mark’s violent aversion to lilacs in Secret Beyond the Door is rooted in a deeply traumatic childhood memory that becomes one of the film’s most potent psychological triggers. Lilacs are not just flowers for Mark—they are a symbol of betrayal, abandonment, and the suffocating pain of being locked away, both literally and emotionally.

The history behind this is revealed in the film’s climactic sequence, when Celia, determined to confront Mark’s compulsion and save him, brings the lilacs with her to the infamous seventh room, where she waits for Mark, forcing him to confront the buried trauma at the heart of his homicidal urges. The sight and smell of the lilacs, combined with the locked door, trigger his psychological crisis. The room, the perfect replica of her bedroom, is surrounded by lilacs. As she sits with the flowers, she urges Mark to search his mind, to dig back into the memories he’s kept locked away as tightly as the murder room itself. It’s here that Mark’s trauma comes pouring out: as a child, he adored his mother, who filled their home with lilacs. One summer afternoon, after helping her gather armfuls of the fragrant blooms, Mark was promised a bedtime story. But when he went to her room that night, he found the door locked—his mother had gone out dancing, leaving him behind. In his anguish, he pounded on the door until his hands bled, and when he saw her drive away with another man, his love curdled into hatred. In a fit of grief and rage, he crushed the lilacs they had picked together, associating their scent forever with loss and betrayal.

Celia’s use of lilacs is deliberate and pivotal in the film’s final act. Celia flees, but love and obsession draw her back. Mark, tormented by urges he cannot control, confesses his compulsion to kill her. In a climax that is as Freudian as it is melodramatic, Celia helps Mark confront the truth: it was NOT his mother, but his sister, who locked him in as a child. This moment of revelation breaks the spell, allowing him to reclaim his sanity and ultimately, their chance at redemption, but they are interrupted by Miss Robey, who, believing Celia to be alone, locks the couple in the murder room and sets the house ablaze. In a final act of will, Mark breaks down the door, saving Celia and himself from the fire—and from the cycle of violence that haunted them both.

The film closes with Mark and Celia resuming their honeymoon in Mexico, Mark declaring that she has “killed the root of the evil in him.” It’s a conclusion that strains credulity, but in Lang’s hands, it feels less like a tidy resolution and more like the closing of a dream—a return to the surface, but not without scars.

Critics of the day were divided. Some found it ‘overwhelming’ and ‘transformative.’ Bosley Crowther of The New York Times called the film “a pretty silly yarn,” but admitted that Lang “knows how to turn the obvious… into strangely tingling stuff.” Variety found it “arty and almost surrealistic,” while others dismissed it as synthetic psychological suspense incredibility wrapped in a gravity so pretentious it is to laugh.”

Yet even detractors acknowledged the film’s atmosphere, its “precisely-articulated suspense,” and its exquisite visual composition. Later critics, like Jonathan Rosenbaum, have argued that the film’s very murkiness is its strength, and some have gone so far as to call it one of Lang’s greatest American films—a rare Hollywood art-movie, as beautiful as it is strange.

What lingers about Secret Beyond the Door is not its logic, but its mood: the sense of wandering through a house built from memory and fear, where every locked door is a question and every answer is another mystery. Joan Bennett’s performance is a study in controlled anxiety, Michael Redgrave’s Mark is a man fractured by his own mind, and Lang’s direction is a vivid illustration of how to turn the architecture of a house—and a marriage—into a map of the unconscious. It’s a film that may not always make sense, but like the best dreams, it’s impossible to forget.

Secret Beyond the Door (1947) Freud, Lang, the Dream State, and Repressed Poison

NIGHT OF THE HUNTER 1955

I’ll soon be diving deep into The Night of the Hunter with a full-blown essay that explores every shadow and shimmer of Charles Laughton’s singular directorial vision. This piece will be part of a larger feature examining Robert Mitchum’s unforgettable turns as malevolent forces—first as the preacher Harry Powell in Night of the Hunter, and then as the relentless Max Cady in J. Lee Thompson’s Cape Fear 1962. I’ll look at how Mitchum’s performances redefined cinematic villainy, the directors who shaped these films, and the way each story blends nightmare, suspense, and a kind of dark poetry. Stay tuned for an in-depth journey into the heart of darkness—twice over.

“A Hymn in Shadow: The Night of the Hunter and the Spell of Laughton’s Dark Fairytale:

There are films that haunt you, and then there is The Night of the Hunter 1955—a fever dream of a movie that feels as if it was conjured from the deepest, most mythic well of American storytelling.

Charles Laughton’s one and only directorial effort, this 1955 masterpiece is less a conventional thriller than a dark lullaby, a parable sung in chiaroscuro and river mist. It’s the kind of film that, once you’ve seen it, never really lets you go; it lingers in the mind like a half-remembered nightmare, or the echo of a hymn drifting through a balmy summer night, serenaded by the haunting songs of chorus frogs.

Charles Laughton’s The Night of the Hunter (1955) unfolds like a Grimm fairy tale dipped in ink and moonlight—a singular, haunting vision from an actor-director who never again stepped behind the camera, poured his love for German Expressionism and silent-era lyricism into this Gothic fable of innocence stalked by evil.

Though dismissed upon release and a box-office failure, time has crowned it a masterpiece, a film where every shadow whispers and every ray of light feels like a benediction. Roger Ebert has referred to it as “an expressionistic oddity, telling its chilling story through visual fantasy,” and Mitchum’s performance as “uncannily right for the role, with his long face, his gravel voice, and the silky tones of a snake-oil salesman.

Laughton, better known as an actor of thunderous presence, approached this project with the reverence of a convert. He called Davis Grubb’s source novel “a nightmarish Mother Goose story,” and that’s exactly what he set out to make: a tale where lambs wander the meadow, shadowed by a circling hawk, and the world is at once magical and menacing. He poured his soul into every frame, drawing on his love of a time when silent cinema and German Expressionism reigned, and collaborating with cinematographer Stanley Cortez to create a visual language that feels both ancient and startlingly modern.

Laughton’s vision was a literal baptism by fire. He approached the film with reverence for visual storytelling, studying silent classics like The Birth of a Nation to “restore the power of silent films to talkies.” He battled the Production Code over the depiction of a murderous preacher and reshaped James Agee’s overlong script into a taut, poetic blueprint. His direction was intimate and experimental: he kept composer Walter Schumann on set, let cameras roll continuously like silent reels, and encouraged improvisation. For Laughton, this was less a film than an incantation—a chance to conjure “the feeling that this is a Christmas party wrapped up in a beautiful package” (Cortez, ASC). His sole directorial effort became his legacy: a dark, devotional work about the war between light and shadow.

Cortez’s camera using Tri-X film is a chiaroscuro dreamscape, turning Depression-era West Virginia into an expressionist shadowy fable, where silhouettes stretch across bedroom walls and the river glows with luminous, phosphorescent, and inky blacks amidst the moonlight. The film’s look is pure storybook—if your childhood storybooks were illustrated by nightmares and illuminated by the soft glow of redemption. Crafting silhouettes as sermons, Powell’s hulking shadow against walls, fingers splayed like claws, and water as both grave and womb: Willa’s corpse serene in a submerged car; the children’s boat drifting past skeletal trees, scored by Walter Schumann’s lullaby of dread. The forced perspectives: miniature sets for Powell’s horseback pursuit, dwarfed by an artificial moon. Laughton and Cortez painted with light like Caravaggio—every frame a chapel of contrasts.

The Preacher’s Obsession: Love, Hate, and Holy Terror:

At the film’s heart slithers Robert Mitchum’s Reverend Harry Powell, who is at the core of the “light” that is hunted by the gathering wolves of darkness – a wolf in preacher’s clothing. With “LOVE” and “HATE” tattooed on his knuckles—a sermon prop for his biblical tales of Cain and Abel—Powell weaponizes scripture to mask his greed. Mitchum’s performance is a symphony of menace: velvet-voiced charm transformed into reptilian coldness. His obsession isn’t just the $10,000 hidden by executed thief Ben Harper; it’s the corruption of purity itself. He marries Ben’s widow, Willa (Shelley Winters), not for companionship but to hunt the secret only her children, the sacrificial lambs -John and Pearl, hold. The tattoos become a visual mantra: “H-A-T-E” clawing at “L-O-V-E,” a duality mirrored in every frame.

The story itself unfolds with the inevitability of folklore. Ben Harper (Peter Graves), a desperate father, hides stolen cash in his daughter Pearl’s doll before being arrested and hanged. His last words to his son John are a warning, that haunts like a curse, and a prayer all at once: “Then swear you won’t never tell where the money’s hid, not even your Ma.”

Enter Robert Mitchum as Reverend Harry Powell, jailed with Ben, who learns of the money. Released, he rides into town like a plague—a locomotive’s smoke echoing his menace. He’s a false prophet who drifts into town on a cloud of scripture and snake oil. Mitchum’s performance is a thing of terrible beauty—he’s all velvet menace and sly charm, with existential, contrary forces tattooed on his knuckles, fingers dancing as he delivers his sermon. He is the wolf in the pulpit, a preacher whose obsession is not just with the hidden money, but with the very souls of the children he hunts.

Powell woos and weds Willa Harper, played by Shelley Winters, who paints Willa with the sacrificial fragility of a trembling sparrow. Willa Harper casts a long and sorrowful shadow over the lives of her children in Night of the Hunter.

Her vulnerability and desperate longing for stability make her susceptible to the predatory charm of Harry Powell, and in opening the door to him, she unwittingly ushers in a force of destruction that upends the sanctuary she tries to maintain for John and Pearl. Winters’ performance is layered with emotional complexity—she embodies a woman so starved for affection and guidance that she confuses Powell’s manipulative piety for salvation, surrendering her own instincts and, by extension, her children’s safety.

And her own safety – her murder—a throat slit in moonlit silhouette, her body dumped in a river—is a still life of martyrdom, seaweed tangling in her hair like a crown of thorns. Winters turns Willa into a moth drawn to Powell’s flame, her sexual longing sublimated into religious fervor as he denies her even the comfort of a wedding bed. Their marriage is a mausoleum; the bridal suite becomes a shrine of denial. Her sexual frustration darkens into religious mania after Powell denies her intimacy, transforming her bedroom into a coffin-like chapel, with Willa praying for forgiveness as Powell’s shadow looms over her.

When she overhears him threaten Pearl, her fate is sealed. In one of cinema’s most unforgettable tableaux, after he slits her throat in their bed -her bloodless face framed like a saint in a shrine, Willa’s body floats underwater, hair streaming like river grass, her face serene as a martyr’s beneath the surface—death rendered as a tragic benediction. Willa’s lifeless body is perhaps one of the most startling, terrifying images in cinematic history.

John and Pearl, now orphaned in all but name, become the film’s true protagonists. Their flight down the river is a passage through a landscape of nightmare and wonder: barn owls blink from rafters, frogs croak in the reeds, and the world seems both vast and intimate, as if the children are drifting through the pages of a haunted picture book. Cortez’s cinematography turns the river into a ribbon of silver, the children’s small boat, like a cradle adrift between darkness and dawn. The journey is scored by Walter Schumann’s lullaby, a melody that is equal parts comfort and warning.

Pearl, cradling her doll stuffed with stolen cash, the children’s river escape becomes an odyssey through a dreamlike American Gothic. John’s watchful eyes hold the weight of lost innocence; Pearl’s doll is a totem of childhood co-opted by sin. As they flee in their skiff, with Powell’s silhouette howling from the shore, their journey—past ghostly barns and kind strangers—feels like a passage through limbo.

Their pursuer, Powell, is never far behind. His silhouette—horse and rider—stalks the horizon, a living shadow that seems to grow with every mile—a true boogeyman in pursuit. But in actuality, the chase is less a pursuit and more like a ritual, a testing of faith and will. It’s only when the children reach the sanctuary of Rachel Cooper, played by the legendary Lillian Gish, that the spell is broken.

Gish, silent-cinema royalty, embodies divine strength. Her Rachel is the film’s moral center—a Mother Goose with a shotgun gathering lost children beneath her wing and facing down Powell’s evil with hymns and unflinching resolve.
—She wields a shotgun and scripture with equal grit. She is Powell’s antithesis: light to his shadow, singing hymns not to seduce but as sanctuary. “I’m a strong tree with branches for many birds. I’m good for something in this world, and I know it, too.”

This line beautifully captures Rachel’s role as the steadfast protector and nurturer of lost and vulnerable children, standing in stark contrast to the darkness that stalks them. In the film’s crescendo, Powell lurks outside Rachel’s home. Their showdown is a battle of songs—Powell’s “Leaning on the Everlasting Arms” answered by Rachel’s own hymn, the house divided by music and conviction.

The climax comes in Rachel’s barn, where Powell is cornered, finally revealed, and arrested, his power broken not by violence but by the steadfastness of love and the resilience of innocence. The stolen money spills from Pearl’s doll, raining cash- a mockery of his quest and all the preacher’s greed and blasphemy. In the film’s closing moments, as Christmas dawns and Rachel gathers her “little lambs” around her, the story circles back to its beginning—a tale of endurance, of abiding through the night until the light returns.

When The Night of the Hunter was released, critics and audiences didn’t know what to make of it. The New York Times’ original review of The Night of the Hunter, written by Bosley Crowther, described the film as “a weird and intriguing endeavor,” later calling it “audacious” and “a difficult thesis.” In more recent years, The New York Times has called The Night of the Hunter“haunting and highly personal… clearly the work of a master.”

It was a box-office disappointment, leaving Laughton so wounded he never directed again. But time has vindicated his vision. The film is now considered one of the greatest American movies ever made—and I would agree – a work of art that fuses horror, noir, and fairytale into something wholly original. Mitchum’s preacher, with his tattooed hands and velvet croon, is an icon of cinematic evil; Gish’s Rachel is his perfect foil, a reminder that goodness, though battered, endures.

Its DNA threads through the Coens’ Fargo, Scorsese’s chiaroscuro, and del Toro’s Gothic romances. Laughton, who never directed again, crafted a sermon on the fragility of goodness—a film where evil wears a revivalist’s smile, and salvation floats on a river under a sky “full of stars meant for everyone.” In the end, it is less a thriller than a psalm: a testament to the children who outrun the wolf, and the light that outlives the dark.

Laughton once said he wanted to make a film “full of the poetry of dread,” and that’s exactly what he achieved. The Night of the Hunter is a hymn sung in shadow, a story where love and hate wrestle in the dark, and where, against all odds, the children abide. Rachel reflected on the resilience of children, specifically John and Pearl, but also all the vulnerable, innocent souls she cares for. After the harrowing ordeal they’ve survived, she looks at the children gathered around her and says: “They abide, and they endure.”

#107 down, 43 to go! Your EverLovin’ Joey, formally & affectionately known as MonsterGirl!

MonsterGirl’s 150 Days of Classic Horror #94 THE LODGER: A STORY OF THE LONDON FOG 1927/ THE LODGER 1944 & HANGOVER SQUARE 1945

Echoes in the Fog: The Lodger Legend and Its Shadows from Hitchcock to Hangover Square

THE LODGER: A STORY OF THE LONDON FOG 1927

Alfred Hitchcock’s The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog (1927) stands as a watershed moment in both his career and the evolution of the suspense thriller. Though it was his third feature, Hitchcock himself would later call it his “first true film,” and it’s easy to see why: here, the director’s signature obsessions—wrongly accused men, dangerous allure, and the shadow of violence—emerge fully formed, set against a fog-choked London that feels both timeless and distinctly modern.

Drawing from Marie Belloc Lowndes’s 1913 novel and its stage adaptation, the film takes its inspiration from the Jack the Ripper murders, but is less interested in true crime in reality it is more about the feverish paranoia that settles over a city when evil seems to be lurking just out of sight, prowling the streets.

The story itself is deceptively simple: a serial killer known as “The Avenger” is targeting blonde women, sending London into a state of panic. Right in the middle of all this, the mysterious lodger—played by Ivor Novello—shows up and rents a room from the Buntings just as the murders edge closer to home.

Novello is both magnetic and ambiguous; his haunted eyes and secretive ways make him suspicious and yet strangely fascinating, especially to the Buntings’ daughter Daisy (June Tripp).

As Daisy’s policeman boyfriend Joe (Malcolm Keen) gets more jealous and the Buntings’ suspicions grow, the film really tightens the noose of doubt around their lodger, leading to a dramatic sequence of accusation, pursuit, and mob justice before the truth finally comes to light.

Hitchcock’s direction, deeply influenced by the German Expressionist cinema he encountered in Berlin, is on full display. Working with cinematographer Gaetano di Ventimiglia, he floods the film with mist, shadow, and oblique camera angles, creating a visual world where fear and uncertainty seep into every frame.

The film’s look is both expressionist and modern: glass floors allow us to see the lodger’s anxious pacing from below, staircases become vertiginous chasms, and the fog itself seems to swallow up the city. The rhythm of the editing—dynamic, almost musical—heightens the sense of unease, while the absence of spoken dialogue only sharpens Hitchcock’s focus on pure visual storytelling.

The cast brings a strange, almost theatrical intensity to the film. Marie Ault and Arthur Chesney are quietly compelling as the Buntings, their growing fear for Daisy palpable in every gesture. June Tripp’s Daisy is luminous and vulnerable, while Malcolm Keen’s Joe simmers with suspicion. But it’s Novello who dominates, his performance walking a tightrope between innocence and menace. Hitchcock’s own cameo—his first—comes early, a sly touch that would become a trademark. Historically, The Lodger arrived at a moment when British cinema was searching for its own voice, and Hitchcock’s film was immediately recognized as a leap forward. Critics hailed its technical innovation and atmospheric power, and it quickly established Hitchcock as a director of rare vision.

The film’s themes—media-fueled hysteria, the dangers of mob justice, the ambiguity of guilt—feel as relevant today as they did nearly a century ago. What lingers most, though, is the film’s atmosphere: a city shrouded in fog, where every footstep echoes with dread, and where the line between hunter and hunted is never quite clear. The Lodger is not just a story of murder, but of suspicion, desire, and the perilous search for truth in the haunting, murky shadows.

THE LODGER 1944

John Brahm’s 1944 adaptation of The Lodger stands out as one of the most atmospheric and psychologically charged takes on the Jack the Ripper legend, setting the tone for the era’s horror cinema. Drawing once again from Lowndes’s 1913 novel, the film drops us right into a foggy, gaslit London where fear and suspicion seem to hang heavy in the air.

At the center are the Bontings, a respectable couple who are struggling to make ends meet. So they decide to rent a room to the enigmatic Mr. Slade—played by Laird Cregar—a brooding man whose unsettling habits and haunted look, which bears the mark of something dark and dangerous, quickly disturb the household.

Slade, played with mesmerizing intensity by Laird Cregar, is a figure both pitiable and terrifying, his every movement weighted with obsession and barely contained madness.

As the city reels from a series of brutal murders targeting actresses, Slade becomes fixated on the Bontings’ niece Kitty Langley (Merle Oberon), a luminous music-hall performer.

Laird Cregar was a remarkably gifted American actor whose brief career left a lasting impression on classic Hollywood cinema. Known for his commanding presence and expressive performances, Cregar excelled in roles that demanded both menace and vulnerability, bringing a unique depth to villains and tortured souls alike. He rose to prominence with standout performances in films such as I Wake Up Screaming (1941), This Gun for Hire (1942), and,  notably, this role as the haunted Mr. Slade in The Lodger, followed by his performance as the tragic composer George Harvey Bone in Hangover Square (1945).

Cregar’s acting was marked by a rare ability to convey complex inner turmoil—his characters often seemed caught between longing and darkness, their emotional conflict visible in every gesture and expression.

Offscreen, Laird Cregar’s life was just as complicated. He was ambitious but also very aware of how his imposing size shaped the roles he was offered, struggling with Hollywood’s expectations of their leading men. This drove him to try a risky crash diet in hopes of landing more romantic parts. Sadly, this decision contributed to his early death at only 31. Privately, his sexuality was something only close friends and colleagues knew about, and his relationships—including a notable romance with actor David Bacon—were often the subject of both gossip and tragedy.

Despite his short life, Laird Cregar’s career was filled with highlights: he was celebrated for his villainous roles, brought unexpected sympathy to his darkest characters, and was praised by contemporaries for his stage work as well as his films. His performances in The Lodger and Hangover Square remain iconic, showcasing a talent that could evoke both fear and pity, and leaving a legacy as one of Hollywood’s most memorable and enigmatic actors.

As Mr. Slade, Cregar’s performance dominates the film, imbuing Slade with a tragic depth. His physical presence—imposing yet oddly vulnerable—makes him an unforgettable figure, whose yes are constantly shifting, moving between longing and menace, as if he’s always caught between wanting and warning at the same time.

The supporting cast brings their own vivid energy: Merle Oberon’s Kitty is both glamorous and sympathetic, while George Sanders, as the suave Inspector Warwick, brings a dry wit and dogged determination to the hunt for the killer. Wonderful character actors, Cedric Hardwicke and Sara Allgood, as the Bontings, ground the film with their blend of domestic warmth and deepening apprehension, their household slowly unraveling under the weight of suspicion.

What really stands out to me about The Lodger is how visually it leans into a moody, noir-inflected style. Lucien Ballard’s cinematography bathes everything in deep shadows and swirling fog, clearly inspired by German Expressionism. The result is a world that feels at once claustrophobic and strangely dreamlike.

Every frame seems alive with narrow alleyways, rain-slicked streets, and dark, shadowy interiors, conjuring a London that feels like it’s on the verge of hysteria.

The camera lingers on faces, hands, and fleeting, telling glances that say more than words, adding to the tension and uncertainty that drive the story forward.

And Hugo Friedhofer’s score? It quietly threads the film with a subtle but undeniable force that adds to the sense of doom, giving The Lodger its lingering, haunted melancholy that hangs over every scene.

Brahm tightly holds the reins—there’s this careful balance between those quiet, psychologically uneasy moments and sudden bursts of violence and panic. Compared to Hitchcock’s silent version, which focused more on suspicion and the threat of mob justice, this film seems to delve deeper into the psychology of its characters, especially Salde, whose twisted motivations are revealed in chilling detail. The story deviates from the novel and its earlier adaptations, but it manages to add a sense of unpredictability and dread. The Lodger isn’t so much a whodunit as it is about consuming shadows of fear and obsession.

The Lodger was released at a time when Hollywood was dealing with all the anxieties that come with war and the lingering shadows of the past. Brahm, a German émigré, brought a distinctly European sensibility to the film, blending that polished Hollywood studio gloss with the moody, intense vibe of 1930s Expressionism. The end result is a film that somehow feels both timeless and completely of its moment—a suspenseful, unsettling meditation on evil, desire, and the darkness that can hide behind even the most respectable facades.

In the end, The Lodger is less a straightforward thriller than a feverish portrait of a city—and a mind—unraveling. With its unforgettable performances, haunting visuals, and lingering sense of unease, it remains a high point of 1940s horror.

There is a memorable line in the 1944 film The Lodger that touches on the paradox of love and hate. Laird Cregar’s character, Mr. Slade, utters:

“To hate a thing and love it too, and to love it so much that you hate it.”

This line is delivered during one of Slade’s intense, confessional moments, revealing the tortured duality at the heart of his character. Slade is speaking to Kitty, who has become both his obsession and his undoing. The quote sums up the film’s central tension—Slade’s simultaneous attraction to and resentment of women, especially those who remind him of his tragic past. It’s a moment that not only deepens our understanding of Slade’s psychological torment but also highlights the film’s exploration of the thin, often blurred line between love and hate.

This duality drives the suspense and emotional complexity of The Lodger, leaving us unsettled by the realization that the two emotions can coexist so fiercely within a single soul and Cregar is masterful at bringing to life the aching duality of a soul at war with itself, embodying both longing and menace with a grace that makes his torment feel hauntingly real. His performance shimmers with the tension of a man forever caught between shadow and light, desire and dread, each emotion reflected in his face like a secret he can never quite escape.

HANGOVER SQUARE 1945

Cregar reignites his role as a tormented soul. Once again, John Brahm returns with Hangover Square (1945), a feverish, noir-soaked descent into madness, obsession, and the perilous intersection of art and violence. Set in Edwardian London, the film follows George Harvey Bone, a gifted composer played with haunting vulnerability and intensity by Laird Cregar. Bone’s life is a study in contrasts: outwardly gentle and unassuming, inwardly tormented by blackouts triggered by discordant sounds—episodes that leave him with no memory and, as we soon learns, a trail of violence in his wake.

The film opens with a jolt: Bone, in a fugue state, murders a shop owner and sets the scene ablaze, then stumbles home, bloodied and bewildered, unable to recall his actions. This pattern of lost time and chilling gloom becomes the film’s pulse as Bone seeks help from Dr. Allan Middleton (George Sanders), a renowned police surgeon and psychological consultant at Scotland Yard.

After committing the murder during one of his amnesiac episodes, George seeks help for his troubling blackouts. He confides in Barbara Chapman, played by Faye Marlowe, who is the supportive and caring daughter of Sir Henry Chapman, a well-known conductor and George Harvey Bone’s mentor, who takes him to see Dr. Middleton.

At the heart of Bone’s unraveling is his infatuation with Netta Longdon, a cunning and ambitious music hall singer brought to life by Linda Darnell. Netta’s beauty and charm mask a ruthless opportunism; she manipulates Bone’s affections, using his talent to advance her own career while stringing him along with false promises.

Cregar’s Bone is desperate, yearning, and increasingly unstable, while Darnell’s Netta is dazzling and cold, her self-interest sharpening every exchange. Faye Marlowe’s Barbara Chapman, the compassionate daughter of Bone’s mentor, offers a gentler counterpoint, her concern for Bone underscoring the tragedy of a man pulled between light and darkness.

Visually, Hangover Square is a vivid illustration of a noir/thriller atmosphere. Cinematographer Joseph LaShelle (Fallen Angel 1945, Road House 1948, Where the Sidewalk Ends 1950, Marty 1955, The Apartment 1960, How the West Was Won 1962) bathes the film in inky shadows and soft, gaslit haze, creating a world that feels both lush and claustrophobic. Brahm’s direction is dynamic and inventive—overhead shots, Dutch angles, and low perspectives lend a sense of instability and tension, mirroring Bone’s fractured psyche. The film’s most striking set pieces—particularly the Guy Fawkes bonfire scene, with masked revelers encircling a towering blaze—are both grandly theatrical and chillingly intimate, the camera swooping and gliding as Bone’s fate closes in around him.

Bernard Herrmann’s score is also integral to the film’s impact, his original piano concerto serving as both a narrative centerpiece and a psychological battleground. The music swells and recedes with Bone’s moods, the climactic concert sequence a brilliant flourish of sound and image: as flames consume the concert hall, Bone plays on, lost in his own creation, the boundaries between art, madness, and destruction dissolving in the inferno.

Hangover Square is rooted in the mood of its time. It starts with Patrick Hamilton’s 1941 novel, but is transformed into a kind of Gothic melodrama that’s full of the era’s anxieties. The Edwardian setting comes alive with all the rich period details—those sumptuous costumes, busy pubs, and clouds of smoke swirling through every scene. But what really sets the film apart is its noir edge, that constant sense of dread and inevitability running underneath it all that defines its style. Cregar’s performance, tragically his last truly, becomes the beating heart of the film. He embodies the duality of a man gifted and doomed. His torment is visible in every gesture, every look, and every move he makes.

In the end, Hangover Square is a story of a soul at war with itself, of love curdled into obsession, and of genius consumed by its own fire.

#94 Down, 56 to go! Your EverLovin Joey formally & affectionately known as MosnterGirl!

 

Under the Radar: The Unseen Side of Film Noir – Part 3 – It Always Rains on Sunday (1947)

Darkness Without Escape: British Noir’s Bleak Horizons

It Always Rains on Sunday 1947

In director Robert Hamer’s masterful film It Always Rains on Sunday, the relentless downpour that drenches nearly every scene serves as both a symbol of psychological downpour as it is one of torrential weather. This persistent rain reflects the bleak, oppressive atmosphere of postwar London, mirroring the emotional turmoil and shattered dreams of its characters.

A bleak, numbing damp seeps through the air, a haunting echo of the shattered, bombed-out dreams of the various characters navigating a single gritty Sunday on the rain-drained streets of postwar East End London where Googie Withers offers a safe haven to her former lover, the escaped felon Tommy Swann (John McCallum).

In a commanding performance as Rose Sandigate, Googie Withers embodies the frustrations of a disillusioned housewife from Bethnal Green trapped in a monotonous marriage.

Boxed in by good-natured yet intrusive neighbors, she grapples with the bitter feelings of envy toward her stepdaughter’s vibrant social life. When her mundane existence is abruptly disrupted by her ex-lover resurfacing, it forces her to confront her longing for the past and the constraints of her current reality.

Susan Shaw as Googie Wither’s stepdaughter Vi.

Concealed in the sanctuary of her bedroom, Tommy stays out of sight while the ordinary rhythm of domesticity plays out just beyond the walls. Meanwhile, outside the house, the relentless threat of police and journalists at her door looking for him will disrupt their plans.

“ But with that desperate situation as its emotional and narrative core, It Always Rains on Sunday fans out into a sprawling, Altmanesque tapestry of East End life.” ( from Film at Lincoln Center)

Condensed into a gripping hour and a half, the film unfolds with relentless intensity, where every moment is imbued with meaning. As day gives way to the nighttime realm, the despair and alienation culminate in a surreal Stratford train-yard finale. Here, elongated shadows dance amidst swirling smoke and intricate rear projections, creating a fever-dream landscape where all narrative threads converge.

It Always Rains on Sunday is a 1947 British film adaptation of Arthur La Bern’s novel of the same name. Arthur La Bern also wrote the story that became Hitchcock’s psycho-sexual thriller Frenzy.

Robert Hamer, who directed the film, also helmed the irreverent Kind Hearts and Coronets (1949), The Spider and the Fly (1949), Dead of Night (1945) sequence – the eerie and disturbing “The Haunted Mirror,” Pink String & Sealing Wax 1945, The Detective (1954) starring Frank Sinatra which dealt head-on with then considered deviant subject matter, To Paris with Love (1955), The Scapegoat (1959), and School for Scoundrels (1960).

The British writers Robert Murphy and Graham Fuller compared It Always Rains on Sunday to the poetic realism movement in French cinema a few years earlier.

The film features a screenplay By Angus Mcphail, Robert Hamer, and Henry Cornelius, with moody cinematography by Douglas Slocombe, who began his career as a photojournalist. Slocombe also shot Kind Hearts and Coronets 1949, The Lavender Hill Mob 1951, The Man in the White Suit 1951, The Servant 1963, and the taut psychological thriller starring Stephen Boyd, Jack Hawkins, and Pamela Franklin The Third Secret 1964.

It Always Rains on Sunday marked the first significant success for Ealing Studios in Britain, one of the oldest film studios in existence. It opened its doors in 1905 and is still operating today.

Googie Withers and John McCallum met while filming It Always Rains on Sunday. They married the following year and remained together until McCallum’s passing in 2010 at the age of 91.

In a striking scene, Rose notices scars on Tommy’s back, remnants of the flogging he endured with cat-o’-nine-tails during his time in prison. This brutal form of punishment was a practice in British prisons dating back to the 19th century and was only abolished in 1948, the year after this film’s release.

Damian Murphy at The Sydney Morning Herald referred to Googie Withers as dubbed the Best British bad girl with a ‘haughty sexuality.’ Read this wonderful article here:

Googie Wither’s performance as the independent, hungry, and disillusioned Helen Nosteros in Jules Dassin’s masterpiece Night and the City was nothing short of extraordinary. Night and the City was Googie Withers’s last film for Ealing Studios, and thanks to her striking performance as a woman trapped in claustrophobic domesticity, it is perhaps one of her best.

31 Flavors of Noir on the Fringe to Lure you in! Part 2

Hermione Baddeley has a minor role as the proprietor of a flophouse. She is perhaps best remembered for her portrayal of Mrs. Naugatuck in the television series Maude or as the maid in Mary Poppins (1964).

British actress Hermione Baddeley as Mrs. Spry.

The film depicts events occurring on a Sunday, specifically March 23, 1947, as noted on a blackboard at the local underground station. The setting is Bethnal Green, an area in the East End of London that had endured significant devastation from bombings and the hardships of post-war life.

It Always Rains on Sunday unfolds over a single, dreary Sunday in post-war London’s East End. The story revolves around Rose Sandigate, whose mundane life is upended when her former lover, Tommy Swann, appears at her doorstep.

Rose Sandigate is a former barmaid who is now married to a middle-aged man with two teenage daughters from his previous marriage. Having stepped into the role of a housewife and stepmother, she navigates the challenges of post-war rationing and a bleak environment, supported by her kind husband (Edward Chapman) as he heals from past emotional wounds.

Googie Withers, Susan Shaw, and Edward Chapman.

Gladys Henson.

Edie Martin.

Alfie Bass, John Carol, Fred Griffiths, and Jimmy Hanley.

Meier Tzelniker.

Surrounding this central couple, Hamer crafts a richly intricate picture of the post-war East End. The community teems with a variety of characters, lively markets, and the story of a Jewish immigrant family.

We also encounter the philandering saxophone player navigating his romantic entanglements, there’s a small-time petty criminal, and his gangster brother, Lou (John Slater), who has eyes for Vi Sandgate’s (Susan Shaw) sister, Doris (Patricia Plunkett), and a group of hapless thieves and idlers whose recent warehouse robbery yielded nothing more than a bunch of children’s roller skates. All trying to make ends meet.

These diverse storylines intertwine, creating a vivid portrait of working-class life in post-war Britain, all set against the backdrop of relentless rain that mirrors the characters’ gloomy circumstances. The film’s atmospheric sense of doom overshadows the characters’ lives with a palpable tinge of noir-fatalism as it offers an intimate glimpse into the gritty underbelly of London’s working-class existence.

Rose learns from the newspaper about her former lover, Tommy Swann, who while serving four years of a seven-year sentence for robbery with violence, has escaped from Dartmoor prison and is on the run.

Tommy Swann, now an escaped convict, seeks shelter from the authorities, forcing Rose to conceal him from both the law and her unsuspecting family.

In noir fashion, there are a series of flashbacks reflecting on the time Rose and Tommy were engaged to be married. Tommy gets arrested for a robbery, and it is quite possible that he may actually be the father of Rose’s young son.

John Slater as Lou and Patricia Plunkett as Rose’s stepdaughter Doris.

The woman-driven narrative offers some unforgettable performances, richly layered and completely captivating. Among them is Rose’s beautiful daughter, Vi Sandigate (Susan Shaw), Rose’s elder stepdaughter; while stunning, she is also somewhat mercurial and entangled in an affair with occasional lover Morry Hyams (Sydney Taffler), the sax player who is very much married.

There’s also Doris, Vi’s younger sister, portrayed by Patricia Plunkett in her first film role. Despite her gentle demeanor and kind heart, Doris possesses quiet strength and is unafraid to voice her opinions or stand firm when the situation demands it. In contrast, we have Sadie, Morry’s wife, played by Betty Ann Davies. Sadie is no fool; she’s acutely aware of her husband’s infidelities.

Sidney Tafler as Morry and Betty Ann Davies as Sadie.

In a particularly poignant scene, Sadie confronts Morry with a mix of resignation and defiance, declaring, “ I know all about you and your little shiksas. I’ve known a long time, even if I haven’t said anything. But I’m not going to have them come here into my house.”  

[Morry has just told off Sadie for buying retail]
Morry: Where are you going?
Sadie Hyams: To get some fresh air. Don’t worry; I’ll get it wholesale.

Rose’s stepdaughters — Doris and Vi.

The film introduces us to Rose in a subtle yet intriguing manner. We first hear her voice through the wall, rousing her stepdaughters with a request for tea on their father’s behalf. This initial verbal introduction cleverly piques our curiosity about her identity and her role within the household. Soon after, we’re granted an intimate glimpse into Rose’s world as she begins her day. The camera follows her through a cramped bedroom shared with her husband, George. We observe her mundane morning rituals – reluctantly drawing the curtains to reveal yet another dreary, rain-soaked day, methodically unraveling the pin curls from her hair that give the impression of shadowy night.

All the while, her husband George’s voice provides a backdrop of newspaper headlines, to which Rose responds with perfunctory interest. However, the mention of an escaped convict named Thomas Swann suddenly breaks through Rose’s apparent ennui. Though she quickly masks her reaction from George, her momentary lapse in composure speaks volumes. It’s a masterful bit of storytelling, instantly conveying to the audience that Rose’s connection to Swann runs far deeper than her outward indifference suggests, hinting at the hidden depths of her character and setting the stage for the drama to unfold.

A poignant flashback transports us to Rose’s past, revealing a vivacious young woman with hair the color of burnished gold, tending bar at a local pub. We witness pivotal moments: her first encounter with the charismatic Tommy Swann, his heartfelt proposal, and Rose eagerly packing for their wedding.

However, her dreams are shattered when news of Tommy’s arrest for robbery reaches her. The contrast between Rose’s former self, full of passion and life, and her present existence is striking. She now inhabits a world of quiet desperation. Her cramped sardine can of a house, shared with two grown women, a rowdy teenager, and a respectable yet uninspiring husband, stands as a testament to her diminished circumstances. The home’s dilapidated state, with rain seeping through broken windowpanes and taking baths in the kitchen next to the stove, further underscores the stark difference between the possibilities of her past life and the nihilism of her present one.

Rose’s first shocking encounter with Tommy Swann is when she finds him hiding in her family’s air raid shelter. He asks her to help him hide out until nightfall. Though she suffers from an oppressive feeling in her life, despite her initial shock when he puts his hand over her mouth to silence her, Rose’s unresolved feelings and lasting affection for Tommy quickly surface. Her concern for his sodden state, “You’re soaking!” she says and fears that he might fall ill betray a deep-seated yearning for their past connection that persists despite the years apart.

Rose’s actions speak louder than words. Though Tommy merely requests food, she goes above and beyond, orchestrating a moment when the house is empty to smuggle him inside and feed him. Her insistence that he rest in her bedroom while she tends to his wet clothes illustrates the years of domesticity that have prepared her, though it cannot conceal the restlessness that plagues her.

 

Throughout the day, Rose consistently proves herself to be resourceful, street-smart, and remarkably composed under pressure. Consider the moments of Rose’s cunning: when her stepdaughter Doris unexpectedly returns home, Rose swiftly conceals Tommy’s drying trousers with a towel. Later, when the police arrive at her doorstep, she brazenly declares she would never assist a ” Cheap crook like Tommy Swann.”

While the constable’s fleeting visit brings with it a stark warning: harboring a fugitive could result in a two-year sentence. It doesn’t deter Rose from continuing to conceal Tommy within her walls. But Rose is no fool; she doesn’t fancy herself running off with him. “ It’s too late . . . ten years too late,” Rose tells Tommy with an expression tinged with regret. “Just send me a postcard, that’s all.”

Rose is a truly sympathetic and relatable character, as Tommy’s sudden reappearance has awakened a part of her that has been buried; this re-emergence of her former lover has reunited the old passions she hasn’t felt since he went away to prison. The scene subtly hints at unresolved feelings and yearning for her past that contrasts sharply with her current life.

She successfully keeps his presence hidden from the family, but it’s Sunday, and she must prepare lunch. She scolds the girls about their misbehavior from the previous night while the husband heads out to the pub as he typically does.

Rose’s most emotionally resonant moment—and Withers’s finest acting—occurs when Tommy confesses that he needs money to get away. Initially, she offers him the last of her housekeeping funds, a gesture that underscores her willingness to sacrifice for him.

When Tommy indicates that this amount won’t be enough, Rose fetches the engagement ring he once gave her, which she has stowed away in the back of the drawer, away from George’s eyes. She gives it to Tommy so he can either sell it or take it to a pawn shop.

However, as he admires the ring, he comments that it’s a “ Nice stone” and that he’ll get a good price for it. Rose realizes with a wave of sadness that he doesn’t remember it as the symbol of their past love. She says nothing to him about its meaning.

Withers masterfully shifts emotions. In the flash of a moment, her expression transforms from love to sadness, ultimately settling into a steely acceptance as she simply replies, ” Had it given,” revealing the profound emotional weight of their shared history.

Jack Warner as Lt. Fotherfill and Frederick Piper as Det. Sergt. Leech.

As the rainy Sunday moves on, the police drawer nearer. While Tommy is preparing to flee, a newspaper reporter acting on a tip shows up at the house, enquiring about her past relationship with Swann. When he catches wind of the situation, he tries to tip off the cops, but not before Tommy assaults him and escapes.

In a moment of sheer desperation, Rose finds herself engulfed in panic, contemplating a tragic way out; she tries to commit suicide by gassing herself.

Meanwhile, the police are hot on Tommy’s trail, pursuing him to the railway sidings. After a tense chase, Detective Inspector Fothergill (Jack Warner), who has been relentlessly tracking him down, finally apprehends him.

As the film draws to a close, we see Rose in a hospital bed, surrounded by her husband’s comforting presence. He eventually leaves the hospital alone, stepping out into a serene sky that contrasts sharply with the turmoil that was.

This is your EverLovin’ Joey sayin’ save a little bit of time to visit The Last Drive In for a rainy day!

Under the Radar: The Unseen Side of Film Noir Part 2: Criss Cross 1949

Fate, Desire, and Inescapable Will: The Noir Aesthetic of Robert Siodmak’s Criss Cross 1949

Robert Siodmak is the unheralded master of noir, and Criss Cross 1949 can be considered his crowning achievement.  Eddie Muller called the above shot where De Carlo looks directly into the camera ” noir’s defining moment.” They have the potential to be happy, and Lancaster is willing to forget the money if they can be together, but she just can’t let it go. Their fate is irrevocably sealed as they drift towards the nihilistic ending, and despite a handful of playful moments, Siodmak never lets up on the heavy, oppressive atmosphere.

“ Its pleasures are so subtle and so sublime you almost have to earn your way to this film, which deserves its place on any list of top 5 noirs of all time. The structure is complex and engrossing. Every facet of the filmmaking is superb. The cast is perfect, from stars to bit players – it has one of Miklós Rózsa’s most haunting scores, and the whole thing is realized by director Robert Siodmak in a way that makes the viewers feel they’re dreaming the story rather than having it told to them. “ – Eddie Muller

Criss Cross 1949 stands as a testament to Robert Siodmak’s mastery of the film noir aesthetic. One of the genre’s most influential stylists, honed from his German Expressionism roots, Siodmak fashions a visual language of composition and camera work that is, as Eddie Muller calls it, ‘ominous yet graceful.’

His expert manipulation of light and shadow, a hallmark of his expressionistic style, transforms ordinary settings into suspenseful landscapes. Consider Phantom Lady 1944, The Killers 1946, and Cry of the City 1948. Three of his most potent noirs, which are on my list of the best film noir, helped define the visual vocabulary of the American crime thriller.

Ella Raines in Robert Siodmak’s Phantom Lady 1944.

Victor Mature and Richard Conte in Siodmak’s Cry of the City 1948.

Phantom Lady: Forgotten Cerebral Noir: It’s not how a man looks, it’s how his mind works that makes him a killer.

31 Flavors of Noir on the Fringe to Lure you in! Part 2

According to French film critics Raymond Borde and Etienne Chaumeton, who wrote the influential book A Panorama of American Film Noir, Siodmak’s complex understanding of human nature “ demonstrates… that even within the framework of film noir, we’re in the presence of one of the finest psychologists of the screen.”

Robert Siodmak’s ability to infuse each scene and weave complex, non-linear stories with a sense of unease and moral ambiguity through purely visual poetry demonstrates to me why he should be considered one of the most influential directors of the noir era.

Siodmak’s films, like Criss Cross, reveal a keen awareness of what drives his characters. They often examine themes of obsession and betrayal within the gritty context of urban decay, and his brazenly bleak Criss Cross represents the height of a fertile and vibrant moment in film noir during the 1940s.

“ Criss Cross should have been the crowning achievement of producer Mark Hellinger, the flashy Broadway columnist who’d come to Hollywood in the late 1930s and taken the place by storm, producing some of the toughest and hard-boiled pictures of the early 40s – things like They Drive By Night, and High Sierra.”– Eddie Muller

Continue reading “Under the Radar: The Unseen Side of Film Noir Part 2: Criss Cross 1949” →

Under the Radar: The Unseen Side of Film Noir – Part 1

Dennis O’Keefe and Marsha Hunt in Anthony Mann’s Raw Deal 1948.

While iconic film noirs grab our attention, films like Out of the Past, where Jeff Bailey’s (Robert Mitchum) past catches up with him lured by the complex and dangerous Kathie Moffet (Jane Greer), and while there’s nothing hotter than the steamy affair between Frank and Cora (Garfield and Turner) in The Postman Always Rings Twice, or watching Walter Neff’s (Fred MacMurray) descent into murder and deception lured by the wiley Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck) in Double Indemnity. It’s no wonder these masterpieces have rightfully earned their place in cinematic history, yet there’s a whole alleyway of shadows, both literally and figuratively, that have flown under the radar. Well worth watching, these lesser-known noir gems are waiting to be discovered.

Films like The Sniper (1952), Raw Deal (1948), and Act of Violence (1948) offer gritty and challenging narratives and are begging for a bit of attention. These overlooked classics showcase the genre’s versatility, exploring themes of psychological torment, moral ambiguity, and the consequences of violence. The Sniper delves into the twisted psyche of a disturbed war veteran turned killer. Raw Deal presents a gritty tale of escaping the past, desire in flux, and redemption.  Act of Violence examines the lasting impact of wartime choices on civilian life. These underappreciated noirs prove that the genre’s shadowy allure extends far beyond its most celebrated titles. I wanted to celebrate Noirvember by peering into the more obscure corners of the genre!

SPOILER ALERT ?

1-The Sniper 1952


The Sniper is a dark psychological film noir that explores the troubling story of Eddie Miller, a disturbed delivery man with a deep-seated hatred of women. Directed by Edward Dmytryk and shot on location in San Francisco, particularly in the Telegraph Hill area, the film was written by Harry Brown and based on a story by Edna and Edward Anhalt. The cast features Adolphe Menjou, Arthur Franz, Gerald Mohr, and one of noir’s finest femme fatales – Marie Windsor, who Eddie thinks played him for a poor sucker.

The Sniper unfolds like a fever dream in the burning, daylit streets, and shadowy streets of 1950s San Francisco. It is a haunting exploration of a fractured psyche teetering on the edge of madness and the manhunt that ensues.

Arthur Franz plays the unbalanced Eddie Miller, who feels compelled to kill women. When he tries to get help for himself, he is met with a lack of interest and sent back out into the world. Miller is a man whose inner demons have twisted his view of women and, evidently, a mother who is hinted at as someone he despises so severely that he finally breaks down and begins a killing spree, targeting them from rooftops throughout the city.

Adolph Menjou plays Lt. Kafka, a gruff and unmerciful policeman who is assigned to the case. As he investigates the killings, Lt. Kafka begins to see the full picture as he tracks down the troubled Miller, figuring out that the murders are not just sexually motivated but stem from a profound psychological fracture and a desperate cry from a mind splintering under the weight of unresolved trauma. Finally, cornering Miller in a cheap hotel, the cops close in. They force their way into his lightly barricaded room and find him surrounded by a small arsenal of weapons. The look on his face shows that he’s relieved it’s finally over. Dmytryck shows his visual flare reminiscent of his earlier noirs, including Murder My Sweet 1944, Cornered 1945, and Crossfire 1947.

Edward Dmytryk’s obscure noir masterpiece plunges us into the tortured world of veteran Miller, who harbors a darkness that threatens to consume him. His voyeuristic gaze, windows to a soul in turmoil, flickers with barely contained rage when he glimpses couples in intimate moments It’s as if their happiness is a personal affront; each romantic glance is itself a gunshot wound to his fragile ego. He perceives every woman he comes in contact with as being untrustworthy and brash.

In a moment of anguished self-awareness, Miller presses his hand to an electric stove, a desperate attempt to cauterize the emotional wounds that fester within and keep himself from projecting his rage outward. But the pain of other’s apathy only fuels his descent into madness, and soon, the city trembles under the shadow of his M1 carbine. As bodies fall and panic grips the streets, Miller’s twisted game of cat-and-mouse with his anonymous notes sent to the police takes on a surreal quality as he begs to be caught before he commits more murders, aware of his sins but powerless to stop himself.

Dmytryk, fresh from his own battles with the Hollywood blacklist, testifying before the House Un-American Activities Committee, infuses the film with a palpable sense of paranoia and urban alienation.

Miller’s crimes reflect the moral ambiguity of a society grappling with hidden threats. The Sniper  delves into the murky waters of criminal psychology, pioneering profiling techniques that would become staples of the genre. Yet it’s the film’s unconventional ending that truly subverts expectations with the after-the impact of its structured violence and ends with the non-violent denouement of Miller’s surrender and society maintaining the status quo. More than just a thriller, The Sniper stands as a chilling indictment of a society ill-equipped to deal with mental illness, its streets teeming with walking wounded like Miller, in the shadows of post-war America in the 1950s.

“The characters found in The Sniper exist in a netherworld that permits humanitarian speculation to surface through scenes of humiliation and angst.” – (from Film Noir an Encyclopedia Reference to the American Style edited by Silver & Ward)

Los Angeles was experiencing their own version of a lone male ‘phantom sniper’ Evan Charles Thomas, stalking female victims, targeting them at random from a sniper’s vantage point the previous summer.

This must have heightened audiences’ fears when watching an eerily similar serial killer-themed film noir. While The Sniper was not directly inspired by the Thomas case, its release coincided with a real-life sniper incident in Los Angeles, creating an eerie parallel. The film’s story had been acquired by Stanley Kramer Productions from writers Edna and Edward Anhalt several months before Thomas began his shooting spree. Interestingly, Arthur Franz was cast as the sniper on August 27, 1951, the same day as Thomas’s first shooting. Despite the film’s independent origin, its producers recognized the potential to leverage the public’s interest in the ongoing sniper case. They capitalized on this coincidence in their marketing efforts, emphasizing the film’s relevance to recent events.

This strategy, aimed at drawing audiences by highlighting the film’s timeliness and apparent realism, was too close for comfort even though its conception predated the actual crimes.

“L.A. saw it happen!” the local ad for the film blared. Chief of Police Bill Parker was said to have signed a letter praising the film’s realism in its “handling of intensive methods” to track down the killer. In his review, Scheuer noted, “The parallel is too close for comfort, but even without the similarity between Eddie Miller and an alleged local “sniper” the picture would be distasteful.” (Source J.H.Graham)

E.R. doctor: Were you ever in a mental hospital?
Edward Miller: Only when I was in prison.

 

Police Lt. Frank Kafka: All I have to do is catch him.
Dr. James G. Kent: You’ll catch ’em, and they’ll kill ’em, and everyone will forget about it. . . that is until the next one comes along. Then it will start all over again.

Continue reading “Under the Radar: The Unseen Side of Film Noir – Part 1” →

Beverly Washburn: Reel Tears – Real Laughter! Part 1

This is the first of two features about Beverly Washburn. You can read my interview with her here.

First off, I'd like to thank Beverly Washburn who graciously lent her valuable time in collaborating with me and guiding me to make this a proper tribute.

Two times a year (every April and October) I get to ramble through the crowds of unwavering fans at The Chiller Theater Convention here in New Jersey.

These events allow us to meet and engage in conversations with beloved actors who stir up a sense of nostalgia for their classic films and television roles, all having now achieved cult status. We celebrate these fond memories and possess a vast appreciation for the legacy of their work. We go to Chiller fanatical about these guests. Some may be a bit austere, but so many are incredibly gracious, funny, down to earth, and grateful for our devotion.

In October of 2023, I went to spend time with my friend Sara Karloff. but also to get the chance to meet someone I've had a long-time fan affection for: Beverly Washburn.

Beverly turned out to be a charming, kind, and genuine person who still possesses that unique intonation to her voice. She has the same sweetness and organically winsome smile she had as a young actor. And I would be careless if I didn't state up front that she is also a champion of animals and has become a true friend.

She might be legendary for her adeptness at weeping, but she can also laugh on a dime. Her laughter comes off without a hitch. It’s a very natural practice for her, showing her marvelous sense of humor with a lightness that flickers from her blue eyes.

Her biography Reel Tears: The Beverly Washburn Story ‘Take Two' ( click the link to purchase) is filled with truly poignant, humorous, and engaging anecdotes about the golden age of Hollywood and beyond. Her writing is refreshing, delightful, and unpretentious. But she is also a courageous writer who shares with bare honesty her very personal journey sometimes tinged with tragedy and her productive career in television growing up as a beloved child actor. Her memoirs include an affectionate forward by her friend Tony Dow of Leave It To Beaver fame.

During the golden years of Hollywood, Beverly Washburn graced the silver screen as a luminary child actor in the 1950s and 1960s. She found the careful balance between comedy and "˜real tears' with the uncanny gift of crying on cue.

A consummate performer, she effortlessly cut across the terrain of both humor and drama, leaving an everlasting mark on the hearts of her audience.

Beverly as Lisbeth Searcy in Old Yeller (1957).

Not only is she the timeless muse who appeared in some of the most cherished movies of the time, but during the Golden Age when television was redefining American culture, Beverly appeared in countless shows as a natural whenever she was featured in the storyline. She always summoned the ability to adopt a serious mood or show with an aptitude for humor that began the moment she stepped on the stage with comedian Jack Benny in 1952. As a favorite child actor during the rise of live television in the 1950s, the little blonde pixie eventually grew into a very pretty ingenue taking the teen fan magazines by storm in the 1960s.

Beverly Washburn appeared in nearly 100 television shows. During her Hollywood years, many of her feature films were nominated for Academy Awards. She worked with some of the most notable directors such as Cecil B. DeMille, George Stevens, and Frank Capra. She also worked alongside some of the greatest Hollywood actresses including Jane Wyman, Anne Baxter, Piper Laurie, Dorothy McGuire, and Barbara Stanwyck.

She was the girl who could not only cry on cue but could reduce the audience to tears. Often asked how she was able to cry so easily on screen, she has said in interviews that she's overly sensitive and just tried to put herself in the character's place in that situation.

Talking to her now, she feels extremely blessed when looking back over her long career, and she never forgets to express the love she has for her fans whenever she's been interviewed. She is also very grateful that her parents were very supportive yet they never pushed her into acting.

She writes in her wonderfully colorful biography filled with joyful photographs and hilarious anecdotes that even though there may have been times when her family might have had only a half of a bean, her mom would share it with anyone. Beverly’s mom and dad were by her side every step of the way and were very well-liked by both cast members and crew. Her mom kept her grounded, humble, and realistic and helped her stay on a good path while navigating the business.

Beverly Washburn grew up in a humble middle-class home in Hollywood California. Acting was something that she realized she wanted to do and truly enjoyed. Beverly is not only incredibly grateful to her many fans, she readily embraces them as the reason she has remained so popular and valued as an actor. And it makes her truly happy when she puts a smile on someone's face.

She followed in the footsteps of a talented family of entertainers, her father's brothers and sisters were in Vaudeville, traveling the circuit with a song and dance act called The Four Pearls. In the 1950s her sister Audrey went to Hollywood High and was a classmate of Carol Burnett. The two became friends and both worked as ushers at the Egyptian Theater on Hollywood Boulevard. Audrey became Penny Marshall's stand-in for Laverne & Shirley and wound up singing backup for Marlene Dietrich in Las Vegas. It was Audrey's show biz career that eventually led Beverly down that path.

Beverly was merely 3 years old when she started modeling children's clothes. When Beverly was 5 years old, she tagged along with her mom and sister Audrey, an acrobat, to entertain veterans at Long Beach Hospital. On one particular occasion, she had a dancing gig at the Capitol Theatre in Yakima Washington. The emcee asked Beverly to come up on stage and sing ‘I'm a Big Girl Now.’ Beverly felt very comfortable in front of an audience. She was a natural.

There she met Western movie star Jock Mahoney – the Range Rider. She was mesmerized by this tall handsome cowboy. He would play a role in setting Beverly's career in motion. Her lack of experience was a hurdle but she and her mom persevered. Beverly's mom saw her potential and hired an agent, Lola Moore, who represented some of the best-known child actors in Hollywood at the time. It wasn't easy at first to get this notable agent's attention. She was turned away by Moore's overwhelmed secretary. But her tenacious mother was not willing to take no for an answer even when Moore's office in Hollywood was overflowing with anxious little girls looking to be the next child star.

In the busy agent's office, her mom managed to catch sight of Lola Moore's photo, so she and Beverly waited in the parking lot. When Moore got back from her meeting at 20th Century Fox, she was met by a little blonde cutie who wasn't afraid to speak her mind. " I sure like your hat, Miss Moore." Beverly flashed that bright smile of hers. Moore who had been an imposing figure had no time for anything but serious business. Studying Beverly with delight, she answered with a hearty " Well you're the only one who does! Know why I wear such large hats?” "No Ma'am I don't." "It's my signature. I want people to know I'm around. I want them to see me coming.''

Beverly was an honest and polite child who looked straight at Moore she said, "I don't know how they could have missed you anyway.''

Lola Moore found this refreshing and laughed and invited the two up to her office to talk. Understanding that Beverly had no acting experience, or whether the camera was going to take to her, Moore set her up with a drama coach Mildred Gardner and she began taking voice lessons, diction, and other important acting techniques. Though Beverly had no formal training, she was a natural. She never got involved as a Method actor. She was briefly taught by Gardner but after a few weeks she informed Beverly’s mother, ” Your daughter has a natural ability to act, and taking lessons would only ruin it.”While the utmost compliment, Beverly has imagined how far she might have gone if she had formerly studied.

This is where she perfected her famous ability to "˜cry' so well. Beverly has described this gift stating that she would think of what she was supposed to be crying about, imagining herself in that situation, and the waterworks would follow. Beverly says of herself that she's a very sensitive and emotional person. TV guide wrote a two-page article entitled BEVERLY WASHBURN EARNS HER SALT BY CRYING ON CUE. In the book Ladies of the Western written by Boyd Majors and Michael Fitzgerald, they included a chapter called ‘Queen of the Criers.’

Beverly loved to be in front of the camera, but when she was ready she was faced with a dilemma. Every time they sent her out on an interview she didn't get it because she had no experience or credits to her name. It was a real Catch-22.

Beverly with Evelyn Keyes in The Killer That Stalked New York (1950).

Then, essentially fate stepped in a couple of months later while auditioning at Columbia Studios for a speaking part in the classic film noir thriller The Killer That Stalked New York which would be released in 1950. Beverly was 6 at the time of filming. Jock Mahoney who was under contract with Columbia, happened to be walking through the lobby and remembered meeting her at sister Audrey's show.

Beverly didn't fit the description of Walda Kowalski, the little girl the script describes as having "˜brown hair and brown eyes' in the film. She thought she wasn't going to possibly get the part because she had blonde hair and blue eyes. Her mother told her in a very soft-spoken voice,” Honey you're not gonna get this part, but just go in and do your best.''

Mahoney asked Beverly's mother why she was at the studio, and she told him that she was going to be reading for a part in the film, and had been getting turned down numerous times because she had no experience. He told her " I'll be right back.'' Later she would come to find out that he went to the producer and raved about all the work she had done even though she hadn't done a darn thing. They believed him and she got the part. On the first day of shooting, Beverly was excited to be sitting in the big makeup chair getting her makeup and hair done which they put in little curls, possibly trying to make her look like Shirley Temple which was fine with Beverly since she was a big fan of Shirley Temple.

The Killer That Stalked New York (1950) is a classic film noir about a woman, Evelyn Keyes, who smuggles jewelry into New York from Cuba. After she contracts smallpox she goes around infecting everyone she meets in the city. The authorities try to track her down before an epidemic breaks out.

Beverly plays the first victim who gets smallpox from Keyes, and that's how they learn about the outbreak. She had two scenes in the motion picture. One is where Keyes gives her a pretty brooch and the second is when she buys the farm. The makeup department afforded her a deathly look by making her as pale as possible, which in B&W made her look grayish. Shown in an oxygen tent, it was a very melodramatic death! After The Killer that Stalked New York, she continued to go on auditions but now she had a big credit to go with her name.

Here Comes the Groom (1951) starring Bing Crosby and Jane Wyman. Beverly with Jacques Gencel.

Because of that one speaking role for Columbia Pictures, other opportunities opened up. After the noir thriller, she was called to a screen test for her next film Here Comes the Groom in 1951. It would be a role in a motion picture directed by Frank Capra and starring Bing Crosby, Jane Wyman, Alexis Smith, and Franchot Tone. The film also featured fashions by costume designer Edith Head and cameos by Louis Armstrong, Dorothy Lamour, Phil Harris, Cass Daley, and Frank Fontaine. Here Comes the Groom was a huge B&W musical, and an important part throughout the film. She plays a refugee who speaks very little French, makes the funniest faces, and shows off a natural sense of comedy at such an early age, as she plays off Jacques Gencel.

Beverly worked on the film for 3 months, afterwards Bing Crosby gave her a beautiful doll that she named Dixie, after Crosby's wife at the time. After filming wrapped up, Crosby signed a photograph for Beverly saying, " I hope to play in your next picture.”

This would not be the only wonderful treasure Beverly would receive from actors. Even Jane Wyman gave her a beautiful dress. While the motion picture was not a huge success at the box office, it did win an Oscar for Best Song "˜'In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening'' written by Hogie Carmichael and Johnny Mercer.

In 1951, her next little part took the form of a theatrical film featuring the iconic superhero, Superman. Titled Superman and the Mole-Men, this film served as the pilot for the subsequent TV series starring George Reeves as the eponymous hero and Phyllis Coates as Lois Lane, the fearless reporter. The TV series ran from 1952 to 1958.

Beverly had so much fun cast as a little girl who plays with a radioactive ball in her bedroom. Two of the mole men (who are not space aliens but come from inner earth) climb through the window and she plays with them until her mother discovers the strange little men with her daughter and screams!

Continue reading “Beverly Washburn: Reel Tears – Real Laughter! Part 1” →

Noirvember – Freudian Femme Fatales – 1946 : The Dark Mirror (1946) & The Locket (1946) ‘Twisted Inside’

The Dark Mirror (1946)

In films such as The Dark Mirror and The Locket, the male psychiatrist is posited as an antidote to the bad female by being "˜'established as a detective figure whose principal function is to investigate and ultimately to eradicate "˜deviance' (represented in these instances by excessive female desire.)'' From Frank Krutnik IN A LONELY STREET; FILM NOIR, GENRE AND MASCULINITY 1991

It is the phantom of our own Self, whose intimate relationship with and deep effect upon our spirit casts us into hell or transports us to Heaven – E.T.A. Hoffmann

”The figure of the double has been manifest in diverse forms. At times the doppelgänger has shown itself as an ether being – a shadow, a reflection or an animated portrait. At other points, it has taken the shape of an identical being – a person of kindred appearance, a relative, a twin.” From TWO-FACED WOMEN: THE "˜DOUBLE" IN WOMEN'S MELODRAMA OF THE 1940S – Lucy Fischer Cinema Journal 1983

In the 1920s hard-edged and gritty crime fiction became popular, and by the 1940s Hollywood embraced them. At the same time Freudian psychoanalysis became a big deal in America. People knew the basics of Freud’s ideas, so Hollywood could paint stories with ideas the audience could recognize, knowing that people would get the main gist. It became the foundation for some amazing visual displays. Dream sequences started popping up a lot in American cinema, most distinctive in thrillers and in particular in film noir. The Dark Mirror is one of the standout films made during the 1940s and 1950s that introduced psychiatry – like – Spellbound 1945 and two years later, de Havilland would star in Anatole Litvak’s The Snake Pit 1948.

Much of film noir's psychological pathology gives rise to obsessive fixations on the object of one's desire. What differs with Siodmak's The Dark Mirror is that the psychotic's fixation lies with their sibling and not a lover.

The Dark Mirror is a psychological film noir released in 1946, directed by Robert Siodmak who worked with shadows in his various film noir/horror/ and thrillers like an artist works with paints.  The film was produced and screenplay written by writer/director Nunnally Johnson who penned a slew of diverse screenplays that spanned the 1940s through the 1960s – including The Grapes of Wrath 1940, and The Dirty Dozen 1967.

Nunnally Johnson, transitioning from writer and producer to director, secured the rights and brought the story to life on screen. The film materialized through a collaborative effort between International Pictures, co-founded by Johnson and William Goetz, and Universal Pictures, marking their inaugural project under the Universal Pictures-International Pictures Banner.

The recently established studios were looking for a well-known name for their picture and Olivia de Havilland who was a huge star at the time came on board. She had recently taken legal action against Warner Bros. to terminate her contract and was now free from the studio's stranglehold.

In 1947, she delivered a noteworthy performance in To Each His Own for Paramount earning her the Academy Award for Best Actress. Following two films, The Well-Groomed Bride and Devotion in 1946, she entered into an agreement with Nunnally Johnson to star in The Dark Mirror.’

The Dark Mirror, like The Spiral Staircase both of which were classic ‘paranoid women’ /  "˜woman's films' stars de Havilland who plays identical twins, one of whom is a knife-wielding paranoiac killer. The casting of de Havilland is significant particularly because she not only starred in a variety of women's pictures but her sister Joan Fontaine was also an iconic star of the paranoid woman's films. Some of the most notable are Hitchcock’s adaptation of Du Murier’s Rebecca 1940 and Nicolas Ray’s Born to Be Bad 1950. The Dark Mirror presents itself as a psychological noir right from the start of the film with the Rorschach blots backgrounding the titles.

Olivia de Havilland engaged in a notable real-life conflict with her younger sister – silver screen star Joan Fontaine. This behind-the-scenes rivalry positioned the actress to confront her own duality in Robert Siodmak’s 1946 quintessential film noir, The Dark Mirror.

Siodmak made some of the most critical film noirs in the late 1940s and early 1950s, including, The Killers 1946, Cry of the City 1948 Criss Cross 1949 and The File on Thelma Jordon 1950. he had left the spotlight that shined on his pictures specializing in terror and became one of the most prominent directors of crime noir and suspense. By the early 1950s, he grew weary of Hollywood and returned to Germany.

In this way, the reception of Siodmak's 1940s Hollywood films demonstrates the ways in which the category of horrors incorporates films now seen as thrillers, film noir, and examples of the ‘woman's film.’ Siodmak brought with him the sensibility of German cinema strongly associated with the art of shadows and horror.

It's clear, that director Robert Siodmak was drawn to exploring the human psyche in his picture, and The Dark Mirror is a perfect example of this. Siodmak was fascinated with the dynamic of the good sister/bad sister which was apparent in his earlier works like Cobra Woman (1944) and The Strange Affair of Uncle Harry (1945).

Siodmak’s penchant for the use of shadow in his other work holds back his enduring use of chiaroscuro in The Dark Mirror. Apart from the opening scene, the only instances where he delicately manipulates light and shadow occur within the confines of the twins’ bedroom.

The bedroom is the place where we are most vulnerable, where they sleep, which is symbolic of the psychological warfare Terry wages against her sister Ruth. There was a historic rivalry and jealousy over the years. The perceived rejections by male suitors, even the adoptive parents who chose Ruth over her. At the end of the film, Detective Stevenson tells Dr. Elliot that he had the idea to lay a trap for Terry because he feared for Ruth's life. "˜'Even a nut can figure out that it's simpler to get rid of a rival than to go on knocking off her boyfriends all the rest of her life.''

A narrative featuring identical twins presented an ideal chance to delve deeper into the realm of the doppelgänger mythology, a theme that captivated him and inspired by Fritz Lang’s Metropolis (1927).

Based on a short story by Vladimir Pozner that appeared in Good Housekeeping in 1945, The Dark Mirror is notable for its exploration into the complexities of the human mind and the manifestation of conflicting identities.

Pozner's story was nominated for Best Story at the Academy Awards, though it lost to "˜'Vacation from Marriage” by Clemence Dane, which was adapted into a British movie released as Perfect Strangers in the UK starring Robert Donat and Deborah Kerr.

Collaborating with cinematographer Milton Krasner, known for his work on Lang’s Woman in the Window 1944 and Scarlet Street 1945, and All About Eve 1950, Siodmak enlisted an old colleague – Eugen Schüfftan, for visual effects. Schüfftan created the visual effects for Metropolis 1927. In the film, over three dozen shots feature mirrors, some to set the tone, but mostly to depict the inner conflict of the twins, highlighting their interchangeable likeness. De Havilland is shot beautifully in split screen using a stand-in when both twins appear.

Though de Havilland gave a very nuanced performance balancing opposing identities, down to the tone of her voice used for each sister, their body language, facial expressions, the subtle arching of her eyelids, and the sister's diverging character traits, Siodmak tried to ensure that the audience would have subtle cues for each of the characters. They were visibly "˜labeled' for us. De Havilland's Ruth is gentle yet timorous and softly spoken. She wrings her hands out of nervousness. Terry, however, is the bolder one, more assertive and hostile by a hair's breadth when challenged. Terry also smokes and is left-handed, while Ruth chooses to favor her right hand.

In a large part of the film, as in so many films, clothes often tell a story, in particular at the beginning of The Dark Mirror the twins wear identical clothing, Irene Shraff's costume designs, monogrammed dressing gowns, tailored houndstooth suits, initialed brooches, and largish necklaces bearing the letter ‘T’ and "˜R' might have been used as visual clues to help us sort out which twin was which, however, this does not dismiss de Havilland's ability to traverse the dueling roles.

It is important to note once we become aware of how unbalanced Terry is, the sisters begin to dress differently. For example: Ruth can be seen wearing a white long-sleeved sweater and conservative pencil skirt, while in contrast – Terry goes to Elliott's apartment pretending to be Ruth wearing a chic black satin dress with a jewel-encrusted pill-box hat. The visual clues summon the fall of the girl’s connection to each other and begin to symbolically delve into the cliché good vs evil through the emblematic use of color coding- black vs. white.

The narrative is framed by the presence of two significant mirrors, serving as visual parentheses for the story.

Siodmak initiates ambiguity with his use of mirrors and reflections: right from the opening sequence there is a shattered mirror which is reiterated or "˜mirrored' at the climax of the film when Terry throws an object at the mirror after she sees Ruth's image in the glass. Throughout The Dark Mirror appearances are deceptions – this is the central substance of the story.

The Dark Mirror is a psychological study of identical twin sisters Terry and Ruth Collins both played by Olivia de Havilland who vex and bewilder Thomas Mitchell (Stagecoach 1939, Mr. Smith Goes to Washington 1939, Gone with the Wind 1939 also with de Havilland, It's a Wonderful Life 1946, High Noon 1952.) who plays surly Detective Stevenson who gets frustrated and ornery trying to solve a murder he is convinced one of them has committed. Lew Ayres plays the role of Dr. Scott Elliott, a psychiatrist tasked by Stevenson to help unravel the mystery as to which one of the twins is guilty of murder.

De Havilland's performance is striking under Siodmak's direction a tough process considering both Collins sisters had to be filmed separately for the scenes where she/they occupied the screen at the same time. Adding to the struggle to make this work was the disagreements between Siodmak and de Havilland who clashed from the beginning over how to approach the way the twins were portrayed. Siodmak was making a psychological thriller and de Havilland saw the film as a character study of paranoid schizophrenia (Greco) "˜'One sister could and one couldn't commit murder, and that's all there is to it,'' the film's resident psychiatrist explains.

"˜'The film suggests but does not develop the possibility that Terry is Ruth's other self, the "˜dark mirror' that reflects the negative potential lurking beneath Ruth's sunny mask. However, the insistence on the separation of the characters into icons of good and evil makes the film a superficial melodrama rather than a probing psychological study. Good and evil do not engage in an internal clash but are presented as the essence of two separate characters, as in a medieval morality drama.'' – Foster Hirsch The Dark Side of the Screen: Film Noir

The film’s foundation rests on the "˜old wives tale' about twins, suggesting that one must possess an inherent darkness"”in this instance, a deep-rooted psychological one. Featuring the dramatic taglines: Dramatic tagline Twins! One who loves… and one who loves to kill! This is conveyed in the film's promotional ads, “To know this twin is to love her"¦ to know this twin is to die!”

When one of the twins is accused of murdering a doctor, both come under scrutiny. Ironically, it becomes impossible to establish which twin was identified by the eyewitnesses, so the law can't touch them.

In The Dark Mirror, Terry, the malevolent sister, murders her fiancé the prominent Dr. Frank Peralta when she realizes that he actually feels more genuine affection for her virtuous sister Ruth, though he is unaware of Ruth’s existence. He experiences a tenderness in Ruth’s and a peculiar absence of emotion when he's actually with Terry. Seeking understanding, he consults a psychiatrist to explore the possibility of a split personality in the woman he loves. The primary suspect is one of the Collins twins. However, the authorities are confounded by the fact that the twins are identical in appearance, making it difficult to determine which one committed the crime. Dr. Scott Elliott is brought in to evaluate the sisters and aid in solving the case.

Dr. Scott Elliott who frequents the medical plaza's magazine stand where he purchases his lemon drops from Terry, is shocked when he discovers that she has an identical twin sister Ruth. Dr. Elliot (Lew Ayers) is called to the district attorney's office to help with the investigation because he is an expert in the study of behavioral genetics in twins.

The Dark Mirror was Lew Ayers’s first movie after a four-year absence acting as an Army medic and awarded three battle stars during WWII. He returned to acting and became famous for his kindly Dr. Kildare series of films which was on the nose having been away for four years working as a doctor.

A darkened cityscape leads to an apartment that unfolds with a nighttime homicide and a shattered mirror like a fractured mind, an overturned lamp, and a man lying on the floor with a. knife stabbed through his heart. It establishes an atmospheric backdrop for a sinister and psychological story where the thin line between the narratives’ proposed trope of good vs evil is obscured behind the enigma of perceived "˜female' duality.

At the opening of the film, it is nighttime in the city and Siodmak masterfully employs protracted camera movements through two rooms in an apartment. He unveils the time of a violent struggle, the time is precisely 10:48 pm. A man has been stabbed in the back. A prominent mirror over the fireplace becomes the silent witness to the murder – shattered – it is a visual testament to the intensity of the attack.

Cut to Detective Stevenson (Thomas Mitchell) assigned to the case, who is interviewing several witnesses in his office at the police station. The identity of the victim is revealed to be Dr. Frank Peralta. Two of the witnesses claim they saw a woman leaving his apartment around the time of the murder. Soon he learns the name, Theresa ‘Terry’ Collins.

Peralta’s assistant tells Stevenson that the doctor was in love with Terry and had planned to propose to her which gave Terry a motive. It was no secret that Terry was dating Peralta. Maybe it was a lover’s quarrel? As far as Detective Stevenson knows, the only suspect is Terry Collins.

The next morning, Stevenson brings his two solid witnesses to Terry’s magazine stand in the medical building, in order for them to lay eyes on her and confirm she is the woman they saw leaving Peralta’s apartment. They are both certain it was her. He begins to interrogate her but is cut off when Dr. Scott Elliot comes by to purchase his well-loved lemon drops. Stevenson continues to put pressure on Terry to give her whereabouts the night before. She is able to detail every move as well as deliver the names of several witnesses who can swear to her presence, including a police officer and her butcher.

Once Terry learns that Peralta has been murdered she faints and seems genuinely shaken up by the news. Stevenson cannot break Terry’s alibi so he can’t arrest her. But this cop is doggedly convinced the girl is good for the murder and drops by her apartment to get to the bottom of the confusion with the witnesses. Then Ruth appears. The sisters are wearing the same bathrobes, though one is adorned with the monogrammed ‘T’ and one has the letter ‘R’ on it.

Stevenson almost combusts from the revelation that there are two of them- identical in every way and he is convinced that one of them murdered Peralta. The Collins sisters are resolute to stay silent. Neither sister will confess to which one has the foolproof alibi and which one stayed home that night. This drives Stevenson to distraction. The interrogation is getting him nowhere, there are no fingerprints on the knife and no way to prove that either one of them was there at the crime scene.

Orphans since childhood, Ruth and Terry Collins are inseparable. They live together, dress alike, and even wear wire necklaces that bear their names with a peculiar"” over-obsessive clunky jeweled monogram – as if they force their identities upon us or perhaps each might be threatened by losing themselves without them. Ruth is older by seven minutes, yet Terry seems to be the more dominant, controlling sister. Terry has a maniacal obsession with Ruth and is driven to prove that she is the superior twin.

The story unfolds – Stevenson learns how Terry and Ruth seamlessly orchestrate a charade, both working at the magazine stand as the same girl – taking turns to enjoy moments of respite – essentially to "˜switch out'' when one of them wants time off.

Under the guise of a singular job (which they cleverly share under Terry’s name), to the casual observer, no one can tell the difference until the murder exposes that they are, in fact, two separate people. Even Dr. Peralta didn’t know he was actually dating twins at the time he asked Dr. Elliott about split personalities.

Terry stands as a mother figure, a notion that the ‘bad twin’ constantly drives home to Ruth by asserting she is protecting her, making it more of a challenge for Ruth to betray her sister in the maternal role.

Among other films exploring dynamics projected by the good twin/the bad twin trope – they are often suggestive of variations on schizophrenia.

Detective Stevenson brings the sisters in for a line-up but they are so uncannily alike, that the witnesses can’t tell them apart.

Because both Terry and Ruth stay quiet, the DA is forced to drop the case against them because they won’t be able to convict with no evidence. But Stevenson is a bulldog and isn’t willing to give up. That’s when he seeks out Dr. Scott Elliott to help him uncover the truth about which one murdered Peralta.

The investigating officer on the case is Lt. Stevenson (Thomas Mitchell) enlists the unofficial help of up and coming psychiatrist, though Stevenson is more of a skeptic about psychology referring to him as a "˜fortune teller' who employs "˜gimmicks.' "Don't you witch doctors treat people with tinker toys?''

Dr. Elliot doesn't ascribe to the age-old superstitions that twins are usually "penalized in some way, physically or psychically."

He believes that "character, personality is the key" – that the two elements which are very black & white are pivotal, though one is a moral question and the other is scientific. Ayers is an actor who often comes across as a paternalistic figure puffs on his pipe and uses softly phrased insights as the even keel Dr. Elliott.

Dr. Elliot says, "Not even nature can duplicate' this quality, "even in twins" so this is what would tell who is the murderer. He adds that "˜one could and one couldn't commit murder, and that's all there is to it."

"˜'the insistent separation of the characters into icons of good and evil makes the film a superficial melodrama rather than a probing psychological study. Good and Evil do not engage in an internal clash but are presented as the essence of two separate characters, as in a medieval morality drama.'' Foster Hirsch

Terry and Ruth agree to be added as another set of twins for Dr. Elliott's research, though Ruth appears to be more wary of submitting to his examinations and acts cautious believing that Terry might be guilty of the murder.

Terry admits to Ruth that Peralta did propose to her and that she did see Peralta the night he was murdered. But Ruth agrees not to talk. She poses the question to Ruth, why would I kill him? Ruth is frightened that the truth will come out during Dr. Elliot’s examinations, but Terry thinks she's smarter than him and can pass all his ridiculous tests.

He invites the sisters to come to his office separately, where he puts them through a series of psychological tests, including the cliché inkblots that were groundbreaking at that time. Dr. Hermann Rorschach created them in 1921 to diagnose schizophrenia but that was modified in 1939 when it was used as a standard personality test.

As Dr. Elliott delves into the lives of Terry and Ruth, he discovers the stark contrast in their personalities. While Terry is manipulative, cunning, and emotionally unstable, Ruth is kind-hearted and virtuous.

The mystery deepens as Dr. Elliott tries to understand the motives behind the murder and grapples with the challenge of distinguishing between the sisters. The film takes an intriguing turn as Dr. Elliott employs psychological techniques to uncover the truth.

Elliott puts the girls through a series of standard psychological tests that seem to imply more of a moral evaluation than a psychiatric one. After Terry gives her impressions of the inkblots Elliott determines that she has a dark inner conflict, clever and calculating, even a tendency toward violence, after she describes "the lamb looks so innocent, but it has two men under its paws."

Terry's answers seem rehearsed, suggesting an attempt to assert her power though she tries to convey a helpless innocence. But Elliott notices the contrast in Ruth's answers right away. She appears very genuine, and is not aggressive, or threatening, with her contemplations more of a refined nature, as in dancers around a maypole and skaters in an ice show. Ruth is more retiring and amiable. This leads Elliott to conclude that Ruth is normal and Terry is the one who is mentally disturbed. Eventually, the monograms are disposable as de Havilland manifests the difference through her acting skills.

As Dr. Elliott delves deeper into the two personalities he begins to fall in love with Ruth, while Terry pursues him romantically. A pattern that is replaying itself. In the past, men have always chosen Ruth over her, while Terry desires them herself.

We learn that as orphans, a couple wanted to adopt Ruth but not Terry, and as they grew up, men were always drawn to Ruth, even Dr. Peralta preferred Ruth though he didn't know why. It was when he was with Terry that he feared she suffered from a split personality.

Ruth isn’t aware of Terry’s psychosis but Dr. Elliott is convinced that she is insane and killed Peralta in a jealous rage.

The narrative appears somewhat superficial, adopting a simplistic approach wherein the individual potentially toying with Elliott’s psyche, teasing him with aggressive insights, is labeled as the embodiment of evil. Meanwhile, the one exhibiting a gentler perspective through her mild and innocuous visions is deemed the epitome of normalcy.

"˜'20 percent of people who see things in the inkblots that expose the "˜'true secret patterns of their own minds'' The results for Elliott point to this"¦ "˜'one of our young ladies is insane.''

During the free association session, Dr. Elliott is left a bit mystified because the only unusual reflex is Ruth's reaction to the word "˜'mirror,'' to which she responds, "˜'death.'' Now he cannot wait to see how Terry responds to his prompts. But being visibly unnerved, having found out from Ruth how she reacted to the word mirror, it is not clear whether Terry would have given the same answer or if she is now toying with Elliott.

Terry is agitated when she hears Ruth's answer which shows some understanding of "˜that mumbo jumbo.' She refers to Dr. Elliott's tests as "˜'kindergarten games’' obviously trying to poison Ruth's faith in the doctor's credibility and that his psychological tests are nothing more than childish trials.

When Dr. Elliott gives them both a polygraph, it is hard for Terry to successfully manipulate her responses. Terry’s blood pressure spikes every time Elliott invokes Ruth’s name. Whenever her sister is mentioned the needle bounds frantically across the paper in a storm of black lines, especially bringing up the subject of a particular boy who liked Ruth.

From these tests, Elliotts makes his diagnosis – Ruth is sane and innocent of the murder while Terry is "˜'a paranoiac- a paranoiac is capable of anything.'' He is assured that Terry merely found his tests "˜'another challenge to her, another opportunity to show the world what contempt she has for it. That was the tip-off."

"A marker for insanity, or at least "˜'abnormality'' for women, then, is the transgression of typical patriarchal authority. The "˜tip-off' to Elliott that Terry is the "˜'wrong'' twin is her effort to thwart the masculine power and rules that are being applied to explain her motives, psyche, and very existence." – THE DARK MIRROR PSYCHIATRY AND FILM NOIR BY MARLISA SANTOS

Though Terry thinks she is putting one over on Elliott with his psychological "˜analysis' she begins to feel threatened by the growing romantic relationship between him and Ruth.

Terry witnesses Elliott and Ruth in an embrace outside their apartment building, but when asked Ruth doesn’t mention it. Terry becomes more desperate to sabotage Ruth's budding romance, something she evidently has done in the past. She decides to seduce Dr. Elliott herself, while gaslighting Ruth, trying to make her think she is losing her mind.

She begins to torture Ruth, hoping to push her to commit suicide and pin Peralta’s murder on her. She crafts illusions, spins nightmares, and conjures conversations, savoring every moment of her imaginative ploy.

Initially puzzling is why Ruth willingly covers for Terry despite being the target of Terry’s cruel gaslighting, nearly driving her to a mental breakdown. As Ruth witnesses Terry’s darker side, she hesitates to betray her, fearing that Terry’s potential for evil, even going as far as murder, might also exist within herself.

Terry starts by telling Ruth that she's been having nightmares, talking in her sleep, and then waking hysterical and terrified. Persuading Ruth to consume an excessive amount of sleeping pills, Terry secretly uses flashbulbs to light up their pitch-black bedroom in the dead of night. Ruth awakens startled while her cunning sister Terry pretends not to have seen anything.

Terry also secretly turns on a music box so it will remain playing after she leaves their apartment, to create the illusion that Ruth is only hearing the music from inside her head.

After all this, Ruth begins to believe she is descending into madness. Her head grasped between her hands she breaks down, – "Something's happening to me, and I don't know what it is. I don't understand it. I'm so scared; I don't know what to do." Pleased with her scheme to drive her sister crazy Terry reassures her –

"˜'Just remember that I'm with you and I'm always going to be with you. no matter what"¦ no matter happens, they can't do a thing without {her} consent.'' 

Terry is suggesting that Ruth is mad, but she'll be there to protect her as always. "˜'We'll be together as long as we live.''

"Terry converts feelings of loss and fragmentation into fantasies of total power and god-like control; she projects lack onto her own sister in the form of psychological disorder."˜' – Lutz Koepnick from Doubling the double: Robert Siodmak in Hollywood

Self-absorbed, Terry constantly seeks approval from Elliott, wanting to know what it is about Ruth that draws him to her. In a crucial scene, she even pretends to be Ruth, kissing Elliott and challenging him to be able to tell the difference. Yet she cannot restrain herself from self-aggrandizing “Terry is the smart one,” the one men usually go for.''

The use of a one-way mirror becomes a visual metaphor and a symbolic tool, reflecting not only the physical likeness of the twins but also the duplicity and hidden facets of their personalities. As the story unfolds, the audience is taken on a journey through the labyrinth of the human mind, exploring the nature of identity, morality, and the thin line between good and evil.

As the walls close in around Terry, she becomes more and more possessive of Ruth: "You and I are never going to be separated, as long as we live. You and I are going to be together. Always.''

Elliott tells Stevenson that Terry is a paranoiac and definitely killed Dr Peralta. Stevenson becomes concerned for Ruth's safety, so Elliott promises to tell Ruth that night about her sister. He calls the sister’s apartment and asks Ruth to come to see him later. But he is actually talking to Terry pretending to be Ruth. Fortunately, Ruth stops by his office right after the phone call, so he uncovers Terry's ruse. Later on, Terry arrives at his apartment not realizing that Elliott knows about her trickery.

In a demeaning and sexist soliloquy, Elliot begins to enlighten fake ‘Ruth’ about sisterhood rivalry. All sisters are rivals for men. How it is stronger for sisters than other women. Elliott doesn’t even take into consideration ‘social class’. This jealousy is ‘‘why sisters can hate each other with such a terrifying intensity.” Considering this misguided theory, the rivalry between twins is even more intense. It is this rivalry that has consumed Terry.

Dr. Elliot –"˜' All women are rivals fundamentally, but it never bothers them because they automatically discount the successes of others and alibi their own failures on the grounds of circumstances – luck, they say. But between sisters, it's a little more serious. Circumstances are generally the same, so they have fewer excuses with which to comfort themselves"¦ That's why sisters can hate each other with such terrifying intensity. And with twins, it's worse.''

He describes how the murder might have taken place. When he confronts Terry about her split personality, she realizes that he was in love with the part of her that is Ruth, even though he didn’t know that Ruth existed. In a jealous rage, she stabbed him in the heart. It struck me how risky this meeting is for Elliott, as Terry is genuinely dangerous having already killed one man. Sure enough, she goes to grab a pair of scissors when the phone rings, and Stevenson gives him the news that Ruth has killed herself. Terry snaps out of her homicidal rage and they rush to the sister’s apartment.

Terry as ‘Ruth’ tells Stevenson that Ruth killed herself because she was ‘sick’ and ‘twisted inside,’ words Elliott used to describe Terry. That it was Ruth who was insane and committed the murder. She killed herself over the guilt. Terry begins to ramble that she is actually Ruth. That it is Terry who has killed herself because she was so jealous of Ruth.

Elliot tries to provoke the fake "˜'Ruth'' into revealing herself as Terry, antagonizing her about her past rejections. The family that wanted Ruth but not her, and the boys who preferred Ruth.

He confronts Terry by telling her how mentally disturbed she is. He tells her while she is pretending to be "˜Ruth' that "Terry is "˜sick inside' and needs help. He imagines that it is tied to something that happened in their past when they were quite young but has grown inside like a poisoned seedling. "˜'more and more bitter and is now abnormal.’'

Finally working with the police, Ruth, who has been reluctant up til now to believe that Terry is dangerous stages her own "˜'suicide'' in order to trap her sister. As Terry begins to unravel, Ruth suddenly emerges from the bedroom. When Terry sees her reflected in a mirror behind her she throws an object and smashes it, symbolically destroying her sister who is the constant evidence of her "˜lacking.'

At this revelation it is all over for Terry and she smashes the mirror when she sees Ruth’s reflection.

By the end of the picture, Elliott and Ruth are united. He asks Ruth, ” Why are you so much more beautiful than your sister?”

"˜'Terry's possessiveness may be interpreted as a desire to absorb Ruth, to eliminate the "˜difference'' between them that haunts her and frustrates her desires.'' Marlisa Santos -The Dark Mirror

Dr. Elliot's comment in the end supports the actuality that good and evil can exist within two identical people as he tells Ruth, "˜'That's what twins are you know, reflections of each other, everything in reverse."˜'

This mental image -  signals the shattering of the mirror by the darker souled Terry at the climax of the picture when she is ultimately caught in her game of deceit, tricked by Detective Stevenson into thinking that the real Ruth has committed suicide. Caught by her own duplicity, she cannot help through her conceit she reveals her lies while claiming that she is actually Ruth and it was Terry that has killed herself.

She tries to convince Stevenson that "Terry' despised her (Ruth) out of jealousy because men always found her more attractive and likable. Unlike the doppelgänger who inhabits an evil that is transferred to the good person, this is subverted with the evil person Terry claiming that she possesses all the good attributes from their double.

The Dark Mirror is often praised for its innovative narrative and psychological depth. The film’s exploration of the duality within a single person, embodied by the twin sisters, adds layers of complexity to the story. Olivia de Havilland’s stellar performance in the dual role is a highlight, showcasing her ability to convey the nuances of two distinct characters.

It is lauded for its psychological depth, but some critics have noted that the resolution of the murder mystery may be somewhat predictable for modern audiences. However, it’s essential to appreciate the film in its historical context, considering its influence on subsequent psychological thrillers.

"˜'Sugar wouldn't melt in the mouth of Nancy, the heroine of The Locket. Yet if we are to believe the evidence, she is a first-class criminal. With this to go on, Nancy brings the wicked-lady psychopathic parade up to date. Laraine Day gives what must be her most fascinating performance. As with so many of these wide-eyed innocents who are supposed to be baddies inside, the spectator maybe have difficulty in crediting her with such heatless villainies. However, there is just enough of a defiant something about Miss Day. More of the spirit than the actual behavior, to raise the shadow of doubt. It is this question mark that holds one rapt.'' "”Philip K. Scheuer, "Laraine Day Psychotpath.'' Los Angeles Times May, 27 1947

"˜'The complexity of Sheridan Gibney's plot was what really enticed me to the material. It was an enigma within an enigma within an enigma. John Brahm, had done a very good horror picture at Twentieth about Jack the Ripper called The Lodger. He was a German- but not too German "” and I thought he would be good to direct this and give it some of the same atmosphere.'' "”producer Bert Granet in Lee Server's Baby, I don't Care

The New York Times (1946) found The Dark Mirror to be a lamentable production that operated as little more than a vanity project for Olive de Havilland, who "˜has been tempted by the lure of playing against herself.'

"˜'Siodmak explained that "˜audiences love a picture like The Dark Mirror because it affords what psychoanalysis call a psychic renovating'' The strategy of bringing all aspects of The Dark Mirror under the rubric of psychological science including even its purportedly positive influence on audiences, is indicative of the representational shift away from the cynical and at times gruesome depictions of psychiatrists and psychological practices that characterized wartime horror cinema. The horror films that went into production after the ebbing of the Shock controversy evinced Hollywood's newfound commitment to responsible depiction of psychiatry. A case in point was the 1947 film Possessed''– Bad Medicine from book Merchants of Menace: The Business of Horror Cinema edited by Richard Nowell.

In 1948 the Screen Guild Theater produced a radio version of The Dark Mirror starring Lew Ayres and Loretta Young. In 1950 de Havilland reprised her role for a radio broadcast at Screen Director's Playhouse.

Continue reading “Noirvember – Freudian Femme Fatales – 1946 : The Dark Mirror (1946) & The Locket (1946) ‘Twisted Inside’” →

Marlene Dietrich & Anna May Wong: Shanghai Express (1932) The Merciful Temptress or Veils on a Train & The Quiet Cultural Warrior or Mythos of the Dragon Lady With a Dagger

"˜'Dietrich is something that never existed before and may never exist again. That’s a woman.” -Maurice Chevalier

”A shaft of white light used properly can be far more effective than all the color in the world used indiscriminately." "¨"“ Josef von Sternberg – Fun in a Chinese Laundry, Mercury House, San Francisco, 1988)

For a century the divine Marlene Dietrich in her enigmatic work in cinema has been a radiant star of the silver screen. A torch singer, Sphynx-like, a seductress in a world where her mystique remains intangible and beyond adequate description. A torch songstress – she was the quintessential cabaret entertainer of Weimar-era Germany. Dietrich began her cabaret performances in 1954, which lasted two decades.

Marlene Dietrich has a world-weary appeal, the goddess of reflexive poise, self-possessiveness, an inscrutable aura of boundless insight, and a sort of subdued confidence. Next to Bette Davis, Dietrich has stirred a fascination in me – maybe it’s her indescribable physicality, the orb of dancing light across her smile. She’s an elusive divinity.

And through her alluring glamour and fluid sexuality, she became an international symbol, a timeless, enchanting muse, whose elegance and allure mesmerized both men and women alike. Her sensuality is daring, she held aloft her humor with courageous ease, and her inimitable style and aspect, are timeless.

Dietrich started as a cabaret performer and worked as a silent film actress at the height of the Weimar years, after which she abandoned Berlin at the dawn of the 1930s and headed for Hollywood with off-screen lover and director Josef von Sternberg.

In the late 1920s, Dietrich gained prominence on the German stage, drawing comparisons to Greta Garbo in the German press. In early 1930, director Josef von Sternberg came to Berlin to shoot The Blue Angel. He'd been searching for an actress who could "˜'exude the electric eroticism of the movie’s cruel temptress.'' (Peter B. Fling NY Times 1992). Once he saw Dietrich on stage he found his purely malevolent Lola Lola who corrupts, demeans, humiliates, and ultimately destroys Emil Jennings cast as the bewitched well-respected elderly professor. The role won her a Hollywood contract, and with her collaboration with von Sternberg, a legend emerged.

(Eingeschränkte Rechte für bestimmte redaktionelle Kunden in Deutschland. Limited rights for specific editorial clients in Germany.) Marlene Dietrich (left) as ‘Lola-Lola’ and Rosa Valetti (centre) in the UFA – movie ‘Der Blaue Engel’ (‘The Blue Angel’). Director: Josef von Sternberg – 1930 Also available in color: Image Number 622600 (Photo by ullstein bild via Getty Images)

Dietrich's characters function both as objects of desire (her face drinks in light like a Brancusi sculpture) and agents of desire, in the grip of consuming, concentrated loves that frequently demand pain or martyrdom. Von Sternberg places this complex figure into many different contexts, from street prostitute ("Dishonored") to absolute monarch ("The Scarlet Empress"). He even tries, with mixed success, to imagine her as an ordinary, middle-class wife and mother ("Blonde Venus"). (David Kehr NY Times 2012 article The Well-Lighted Agent of Desire)

Dietrich and von Sternberg "˜'embarked on a mad experiment to push photographing well to the furthest limits of the possible "¦ Who cast her as angel and devil – amoral blithely destructive – detected a lustrous vitality beneath this mask of restraint- and she was, in fact, fiercely ambitious – but the pose of not giving a damn, which she made challenging and seductive was what he wanted.'' – (Imogen Sara Smith)

From Dietrich – flowed the look of delirious eroticism, an inscrutable quintessence as she became a golden-haired blonde, her face framed by lighting and makeup that made her arched brows, cheekbones, and mesmeric blue eyes aristocratic, a persona so richly textured as the roles she embodied: a siren, victim, predator, or lover.

In her role in Morocco in 1930 she adopted male attire which was used to indicate sexual experience. (Source: Catherine Constable -Thinking in Images: Film Theory, Feminist Philosophy and Marlene Dietrich).

Not merely provocative -Dietrich’s transcends gendered attire, extending beyond donning men’s clothing or bestowing a kiss upon a woman's surprised lips in the crowd, prompting startled, bashful laughter. She effortlessly appropriates other attributes typically reserved for men: their privilege, self-assuredness, sexual dominance, and emotional detachment. What truly distinguishes her, even more than her nonchalant mastery of her role and her blithe signals, is her unmistakable air of indifference.

"˜'Aloof and calm, she continues her meticulous preparations: dusting off and donning a top hat, straightening her tie, slipping into a tailcoat. She strolls onstage and surveys the jeering audience inscrutably through a scrim of cigarette smoke, from under eyelids dragged down by the weight of knowingness and thick, curling eyelashes. The close-ups is killing in its beauty.'' – Imogen Sara Smith – Morocco (1930)

The Dietrich persona, embodied by the aphrodisiacal Lola-Lola, the iconic cabaret songstress invested in a rakish top hat and sheer silk stockings in The Blue Angel in 1930, was a reflection of a non-conformist, an unrestrained libertine who picked her lovers, made her way in the world financially, and regarded sexuality as an intriguing pursuit of pleasure. Up on the screen, Dietrich personified the audience's wish fulfillment.

"˜'In emotional scenes, she often has a look of blank shock and numbness, sometimes with a fleeting wildness in her dry eyes – the look of someone who cannot lose control, who freezes up in the face of strong feeling. It is a limitation used to best advantage, make her seem inaccessible rather than inadequate.'' (Imogen Sara Smith)

Critic Kenneth Tynan described Lola Lola's self-expression as “a serpentine lasso whereby her voice casually winds itself around our most vulnerable fantasies"¦ She has sex but no positive gender. Her masculinity appeals to women and her sexuality to men.”

She was a fashion trendsetter on screen and in her personal life, often dressed in tailored trousers and mannish attire. The actress pioneered the “Dietrich silhouette,” demonstrating that women could maintain their femininity while wearing masculine clothing that still highlighted a slender figure with subtle hips and bust line.

Dietrich herself manifested an individualist charisma in her personal and public persona as with many of her earlier roles, Mademoiselle Amy Jolly in Morocco 1930, Marie Kolverer -(X27) in Dishonored 1931, Helen Faraday in Blonde Venus 1932, and the corrupting vamp Concha Perez in The Devil is a Woman 1935 which was her particular favorite.

von Sternberg & Dietrich –Blonde Venus 1932

“The cool, bright face that didn’t ask for anything, that simply existed, waiting — it was an empty face, he thought; a face that could change with any wind of expression. One could dream of anything. It was like a beautiful empty house waiting for carpets and pictures. It had all possibilities — it could become a palace or a brothel.” (Erich Maria Remarque).

Eventually, the top executives at Paramount wanted to maintain the box office attraction of their big investment in Dietrich and blocked von Sternberg from directing her in any other pictures. He was losing money for them with his opulent storylines that were growing more self-indulgent and the narratives anemic. They cast her in two successful romantic comedies, her first Desire (1936) with Gary Cooper as her leading man. Then a satirical western Destry Rides Again in 1939 where Dietrich plays a free-spirited fireball who sings in a saloon and seduces Sheriff James Stewart. There's a raucous scene that features a hair-pulling, face-slapping brawl between Dietrich and Una Merkel.

Some of her more well-known films include – As a German Noblewoman in von Sternberg's The Scarlett Empress in 1934, The Garden of Allah in 1936, as Lady Maria Barker in Ernst Lubitsch's Angel in 1937, As Bijou the saloon singer in Tay Garnett's Seven Sinners in 1940, as the saloon owner Cherry Malotte in The Spoilers in 1942, she played a glamorous gypsy in Mitchell Leisen’s Golden Earrings in 1947, as a manipulative Berlin cabaret singer in Billy Wilder’s A Foreign Affair 1948, as a conniving murderess in Hitchcock's Stage Fright in 1950. As a saloon manager hiding outlaws in Fritz Lang’s Rancho Notorious in 1952, as a duplicitous wife in Billy Wilder's Witness for the Prosecution in 1957, as the cynical madame of a brothel in Orson Welle's Touch of Evil in 1958, and as an aristocratic widow in Stanley Kramer's Judgment at Nuremberg in 1961. Her last picture was in 1978 – she played Baroness von Semering alongside David Bowie in Just a Gigolo.

"˜'Touch of Evil provided Miss Dietrich with one of her most memorable lines. She admonished the character played by the corpulent Welles to “lay off the candy bars.” (Peter B. Flint New York Times 1992)

During WWII she became a symbol of free Germany, outspoken against Hitler, financed the escape of many people from Nazi occupation, and entertained Allied troops and prisoners of war. "˜'Tirelessly and good-humoredly, she roughed it with the G.I.’s, standing patiently in food lines, washing with snow, and sleeping in dugouts and ruins, often near the front lines. She sang her movie songs, the international wartime ballad “Lili Marlene” and some current songs, and even played a musical saw, a skill she had mastered for the Berlin stage.'' (Peter B. Flint New York Times 1992)

The troops fell in love with her. How could they not? After the war, she was awarded the Medal of Freedom, the highest civilian honor the United States Government bestows. France named her a Chevalier of the Legion of Honor and Belgium dubbed her a Knight of the Order of Leopold.

After 5 decades on stage, film, television, and lilting torch songs in cabarets, Dietrich died in 1992 at the age of 90 at her flat in Paris.

The inscrutable Anna May Wong, the pioneering Chinese-American actress, was born in 1905 above her family’s Chinese laundry in Los Angeles, Wong quickly developed a passion for the world of cinema. From a young age, she earned a reputation as the "˜curious Chinese child' who would frequently visit film sets in Chinatown. At the age of 17, Wong seized her debut leading role in the silent film “Toll of the Sea” in 1922. Throughout her career, Wong encountered obstacles and racial discrimination. Not only were roles limited due to the film industry’s decision to primarily cast Western actors in leading Asian roles, but Hollywood and the Hays Code had very harsh rules against miscegenation, which restricted her from any on-screen kisses with non-Asian actors, even if that actor was portraying an Asian character. Further limiting her career was the desire producers had to cast Western actors in leading Asian roles.

In Shanghai Express, Wong’s performance as Hui Fei was vivified with dignity and primacy which challenged the pervasive stereotypes and expectations Hollywood had of Asian actresses during the 1930s.

At the beginning of her career, the Chinese press with the addition of the Nationalist government had been critical of Anna May Wong for her on-screen sexuality that perpetuated negative stereotypes of Chinese women.

On the screen goddess Anna May Wong was fond of saying, that she died a thousand deaths.

In Tiger Bay she sacrifices her life – as Lui Wong she stabs her wrist with a poisoned ring. Dying, she whispers an ancient Chinese poem. As Shosho the London flapper and ”Chinese Dancing Wonder,” was shot in the chest by a jealous suitor, she appeared as Taou Yuen, in Java Head 1934 an exquisite Qing Dynasty princess transported to cold grey Victorian Bristol, she indulges in opium while wearing spectacular Peking Opera costume and reviled by high society and righteous members of the church -Taou Yuen's grace and decency are ignored, and as Wong dignity rises above the dialogue the film is riddled with contradictions. With the cast of characters condemning her "barbaric" rites, the undertone is that Chinese culture is like a dangerous drug like opium which provokes the senses and awakens forbidden desires.

As Lotus Flower in The Toll of the Sea (1922) Wong plays an innocent Hong Kong girl abandoned by her unambitious American lover, she throws herself into the provoking sea.

As Shosho, it was her erotic triumph in 1929 British silent ‘Picadilly’ directed by E. A. Dupont – set in the backdrop of London, she outshines Gilda Gray, known as the “Queen of Shimmy,” in her role as Shosho, the scullery maid who captures the affection of a nightclub owner who happens to be Gilda's lover. She becomes an overnight sensation when he puts her on stage.

Perhaps it had something to do with her costume — a scanty, gilded interpretation of a vaguely Indonesian warrior outfit, purchased (at Shosho’s insistence) in Limehouse, London’s Chinatown. More likely it’s Wong’s intensity, toughness, and vibrant sensuality, showcased in a film that played off the fears and temptations of miscegenation. (From The Dragon Lady and the Quiet Cultural Warrior By Leslie Camhi New York Times article 2004)

Wong's big break came a year later when Hollywood's jeweled prince Douglas Fairbanks cast her in his over-the-top Orientalist pageant The Thief of Baghdad in 1924.

The Mongol slave girl, attired in a revealing bikini, turns traitor to her mistress"”a Persian princess and the object of Fairbanks’s affection"”by acting as a spy for a Mongol prince. Wong’s outrageous scene-stealing moment comes when she tremors and writhes as Fairbanks’s knife takes away her last breath.

That epic picture made Wong an international star, but it was not enough to deliver her from supportive roles that added to her "˜Oriental intrigue' and "˜local color' while white actors were made up in "˜yellowface' like Warner Oland who starred in the Charlie Chan detective series, were routinely cast as Asians. In addition to being relegated to cultural caricatures, the taboos of mixed-raced romance kept Wong from taking on the lead role if she couldn't kiss her co-star. As a seductress, she was doomed to certain death. Her faithless servants, gangsters’ molls, and formidable dragon ladies — in the Hollywood parts that awaited her"” she often met unfortunate ends.

"I was tired of the parts I had to play"¦ Why should we always scheme, kill, (and) rob?"

In the casting of the film The Good Earth based on Pearl S. Buck's popular novel, Wong deeply wanted to play the lead role of Olan and fought hard to be cast in the part but was passed over for German actress Luise Rainer. Most insulting, she was offered the part of an unsympathetic character in the film, which she refused. "If you let me play O-lan, I will be very glad. But you're asking me "“ with Chinese blood "“ to do the only unsympathetic role in the picture featuring an all-American cast portraying Chinese characters."

Anna May Wong's sophistication, both in front of the camera and in her personal life, was a captivating blend of traditional Chinese dress and the glamorous fashion of 1930s Hollywood. Wong dedicated herself to infusing authenticity into even her most minor roles by meticulously incorporating genuine Chinese hairstyles and costumes, which she often used from her own collection.

Though her elegance and allure and pursuit of authenticity are undeniable, Wong's characters could still be seen as the embodiment of the racist stereotypes perpetuated by a studio system that struggled to envision and articulate positive roles for Asian actors. She wishes to break the bonds of the Dragon Lady trope.

Publicity stills from Limehouse Blues (1934)

On January 14, 1932, a Chinese newspaper ran with the headline "Paramount Utilizes Anna May Wong to Produce Picture to Disgrace China.

"Her specialty is to expose the conduct of the very low caste of Chinese," the editorial ran on, citing her turn as "a half-robed Chinese maid in The Thief of Bagdad [sic]. Although she is deficient in artistic portrayal, she has done more than enough to disgrace the Chinese race."

In Shanghai Express, Anna May Wong gives an enigmatic performance as Hui Fei, the elliptical warrior who brings an extra layer of agency and nuance to the film as her character converges with Dietrich's Shanghai Lily. Hui Fei is acute, resourceful, and instrumental in the prevailing plot line.

Wong's portrayal of Hui Fei is a marked departure from the conventional exoticized and orientalization of surrendering girls she was more often confined to by Hollywood during the era.

Anna May Wong at Hollywood’s Music Box Theater for the opening of The Old Woman 1933.

As Hui Fei, Wong manifests "˜'an inordinately graceful Confucian courtesan with nerves of steel (and traveling companion to Marlene Dietrich’s notorious prostitute Shanghai Lily), who disappears from a crowded train platform amid the flashes of news photographers after collecting her reward for murdering a brutal Chinese warlord"¦ Wong’s presence in “Shanghai Express” can be seen as a counterpoint to Marlene Dietrich’s character. While Dietrich’s Shanghai Lily is an embodiment of Western allure and independence, Wong’s Hui Fei represents a more complex portrayal of an Asian woman navigating her own path in a racially charged and patriarchal world. This contrast between the two actresses and their characters adds depth to the film and highlights the intersectionality of their struggles in the film industry.'' -(Leslie Camhi The Dragon Lady and the Cultural Warrior -New York Times article 2004)

During the 1930s the radically individualistic Wong traveled between Europe and Hollywood and in 1936 she embarked on a year's stay in her spiritual homeland China, in search of a better way to represent Chinese women in her work, where she had been subjected to roles as women of little morality who live by the flesh.

Like numerous actors from her era, Wong concluded her career in the emerging realm of television. She briefly took on a role in “The Gallery of Madame Liu Tsong,” portraying a Chinese art dealer and detective entangled in the subterfuge of the international art world. Her ultimate promotional photograph, captured during her appearance in “Portrait in Black” (1960), a film she hoped would ignite her career once more, features her as a maid, caressing a Siamese cat. She died a year after the film's release.

Continue reading “Marlene Dietrich & Anna May Wong: Shanghai Express (1932) The Merciful Temptress or Veils on a Train & The Quiet Cultural Warrior or Mythos of the Dragon Lady With a Dagger” →